UPDATE: Telstra investigated over schoolboy death

Telstra is being investigated following a schoolboy's fatal asthma attack while the family's defunct phone line was waiting to be fixed.

Ten-year-old Sam Boulding, who lived with his family on a property near Kergunyah in north-eastern Victoria, died while the family phone was out of order, despite his mother allegedly begging Telstra to fix the phone for 10 days beforehand.

Mrs Boulding reportedly blames Telstra for her son's death, saying emergency services would have been able to offer medical assistance over the phone and tell the family what to do.

The Australian Communications Authority (ACA) was ordered to carry out the investigation into the national carrier last night by the Minister for communications, Senator Alston.

"The investigation will be completed as quickly as possible and I expect the full co-operation of Telstra," ACA acting chairman Dr Bob Horton said in a statement.

Telstra CEO Ziggy Switkowski confirmed that the company would fully co-operate with the investigation.

"I am deeply saddened for the family and very disturbed by the tragedy," Switkowski said in a statement.

The country's incumbent has ordered its own review of the case and auditors PricewaterhouseCoopers will report its findings to Switkowski within a week.

"We are reviewing this tragedy with the utmost seriousness and urgency. We will take whatever action is found to be necessary," he said.

The report by PricewaterhouseCoopers will be shared with the ACA.

The ACA investigation is being conducted under Part 2b of the Telecommunications Act 1997, that provides for the ACA to investigate "...matters relating to telecommunications".

The terms of reference of the investigation will be finalised today.

The ACA will report to Senator Alston.

Advertisement

Talkback 10 comments

    Perhaps Telstra SHOULD outsour ...A Richardson -- 15/02/02

    Perhaps Telstra SHOULD outsource its maintenance and repairs...just another in a long line of corporate mishaps by this telco, only this time it has led to tragedy. Add this to the top of the Hall of Shame list!

    what a load of xxxx....it is s ...Anonymous -- 15/02/02

    what a load of xxxx....it is sad a boy died but there is nothing someone on the end of the phone can do to fix a asthma attack..its quite simple if the reliever drug isnt at hand to help the breathing of a asthmatic then you can do nothing except to try keep them calm till it passes or medicine is available...i know i am a asthmatic

    im sorry for the loss of this ...Anonymous -- 15/02/02

    im sorry for the loss of this childs life but there comes a point in a persons life that they must accept that maybe the parents are at fault if they knew about there sons condition then maybe they should have done a lesson on CPR ets. What happened 15 years ago when phones were not in 100% of the houses around .. can we go back then and blame telstra for that to.. Telstra has poor managment but this is not there fault if any thing maybe they should assess the remoteness or where they live or get on with there neighbours..

    Though tradgic... You can't pu ...Rob -- 15/02/02

    Though tradgic... You can't push the blame onto another party. The parents were aware of the condition and should have made other arrangements, considering the length of the outage (some 10 days).

    The newsworthy part of the story is, Alston the ludite, has actually come out of his hole. Tell me again... What does he do? I know for sure he doesn't do anything "Good" for IT in Australia!

    But that doesn't matter, as long as Telstra's key Puppet keeps Telstra's share price climbing. Hell can freeze over before he'll lift a finger.

    While it's no suprise that Tel ...Anonymous -- 15/02/02

    While it's no suprise that Telstra's service is terrible, the sad death of this young boy simply highlights how bad it really is. Are Telstra to blame for the child's death? I don't know. They surely didn't help. This case does illustrate however the importance of telecommunications to rural and remote households. What makes me mad is the reports I've heard about Telstra not wanting to carry out the repairs because they were unwilling to fork out the bill for overtime. What a great icon of Australian business.

    A tragic death, certainly a ne ...Anonymous -- 15/02/02

    A tragic death, certainly a needless death, but who is to blame? Should Telstra take responsibility for their lack of provision of the essential telephone line that could have been used to call 000? While some argue that Telstra could not possibly be to blame and the parents are totally at fault, consider this...

    A child requires daily dialysis and the machine requires constant electricity in order to run. There is a blackout one day and the parents quickly call the provider asking for return of the essential service and state why they require it. The provider fails to repair the electricty which results in the parents calling a second, then a third time about lack of power. After 10 days the child dies from complications before abulance staff can reach him.

    Who is to blame? Should the parents have invested in a generator in the off-chance the power would be cut for such a long period of time? Is the electricity provider to blame for not repairing the fault that caused the lack of power even after being notified of the fault and told why repair was essential? What about after the provider was notified a second, third, forth or fifth time?

    Telstra are paid to provide a service which, in rural areas (often without mobile coverage) is essential. If they are notified numerous times of a failure in that service and they refuse to fix that service, even after being notified that medical reasons required the service, can they possibly hope to wipe their hands of the issue and state "We are not to blame"?

    Telstra will use the inclement ...Anonymous -- 16/02/02

    Telstra will use the inclement weather excuse. They will never accept blame for something because of lawsuits. Nothing will change from this. McDonald$ did the same thing when a kid was electrocuted. They got off scott free. Funny, Man$feild was in that Corp then and now in Tel$tra. What a coincidence!

    Look! Overtime is expensive! ...Zigg Baby -- 16/02/02

    Look! Overtime is expensive!

    We were too busy spending money on advertising and sports sponsorship!

    How are we meant to fix phone lines too?

    It's a competitive market you know.. ahhahahahahaha

    O.K., maybe Telstra deserves s ...Anonymous -- 18/02/02

    O.K., maybe Telstra deserves some of the blame, but based on the limited facts provided in the story I'd say the family is more directly responsible.

    The way the story has been presented, the mother begged Telstra to fix the problem because she knew her son had that particular medical condition. Mention was made that emergency operators could have given instructions over the phone. But if the child's asthma was known to be that bad why did they not have an emergency-procedures chart on the loungeroom wall and instruction cards in their wallets? Why didn't they invest in some other means of communication like radio and/or satellite phone of some kind?

    The people I know with serious asthma problems require drugs (usually some kind of steroid) to fend off bad attacks, something that couldn't be done by phone.

    Even if the fault had been fixed promptly, what was to stop a storm knocking the lines out just when they needed them?

    Now, I'm not sure of the full ...Anonymous -- 19/02/02

    Now, I'm not sure of the full background here, but there seems to be a lot of jumping to conclusions. So far, everyone has assumed the boy had chronic severe asthma. Did he really, or was it a chronic attack? There is a difference. I know a few people with asthma, and have extensive experience in dealing with the condition on a day-to-day experience. And one thing I have found is that even people with mild cases can have sudden, severe attacks, far more severe than anything they normally suffer.

    If this was such a rogue attack, the parents may not have been prepared for something that severe. And there is often little a civilian can do. You think the medical authorities are going to release extremely powerful, controlled drugs to just anyone? The best Joe Citizen can hope to get is a nebuliser and premeasured medication ampoules, and in a truly severe attack even that won't help. Only the direct and immediate assistance of emergency services can do anything.

    Now, I'm not saying this was the case, but perhaps instead of people barking like junkyard dogs and snapping at either Telstra or the family, we need to look at the big picture, at all the facts. And not jump to conclusions...

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

Tags

Back to top

Featured