The curious incident of the text messages at midnight

Mobile phone users have been complaining that text messages sent by friends and family based in Europe on New Years' eve have taken up to 5 days to make the 17,000 kilometre journey.

The use of text messages, which are up to 160 characters long and usually arrive within seconds, has exploded over the past few years. Optus said, during the New Year celebrations, almost 16 million text messages were sent from its network while Telstra said it expected around 22 million to be sent over the same period.

However, neither of the companies could explain why replies from Europe, which is the most popular international destination for text messages during the holiday season, were taking anywhere from 2 to 5 days to reach their final destination.

Kirsty Potter, a student from Scotland who is connected to the Virgin network, is a typical example. According to Potter, she sent a number of text messages home on New Years' eve but did not receive any replies until Wednesday January 5, even though the return messages were sent at around 3am on New Year's day -- Sydney time.

"I got the first reply on Wednesday (January 5) and have got more over the next few days. One of my friends, who is on Vodafone, got 7 messages in one go on Thursday -- and they were all sent on New Years' day," said Potter.

Warren Chaisatien, research manager for wireless and mobility at analyst firm International Data Corp, said users expect a small delay during busy periods -- such as Christmas and New Years' -- but he finds a delay of a few days "extraordinary".

"One of the reasons why SMS took off in the first place is because it is immediate, spontaneous and also very personal. The implication is that SMS loses its primary functionality -- the immediacy," said Chaisatien.

However, mobile phone operators say that although the Christmas and New Year period is the busiest of the year, their networks were only experiencing delays of a "few minutes" and could not explain exactly why international texts may have taken so long.

According to a spokesperson from Telstra, its customers may have experienced a delay of up to 3 minutes when sending text messages within Australia but the company said any delays on the international network were out of its control.

"We upgrade our network by putting in extra base station cells around the busiest places in Australia - not just Sydney. We do that to cope with the extra load and even so we had delays of up to 3 minutes," the spokesperson said.

Optus also admitted its customers may have experienced delays when sending text and picture messages during the new year celebrations but the company denies that the delay was more then a few minutes.

"There was some congestion at midnight on New Years' eve -- that was the busiest time. But it certainly wasn't a couple of days; the largest delay was only a few minutes," the Optus spokesperson said.

According to Optus, any delay was due to international network operators not preparing their systems for a surge in SMS traffic.

"If it is from overseas, we are relying on networks that we don't own. If the text messages are coming from the UK then we rely on the UK network and it would be an issue for them," the spokesperson said.

A spokesperson from Vodafone agreed, stating that there were some delays on the Australian networks but nothing more than a few minutes.

"There is so much interoperability between the carriers so it makes it difficult to work out exactly where the delays occurred. This is an incredibly busy time of year and if there were delays they occurred before the messages got into Australia," the Vodafone spokesperson said.

Have you experienced delays in sending or receiving text messages over the holiday period? Tell us about it by using the talkback below or e-mail the edit team.

Advertisement

Talkback 5 comments

    What do they expect? SMS was o ...Anonymous -- 08/01/05

    What do they expect? SMS was only ever designed as a low-priority application. Telcos always have disclaimers that SMS delivery is not guaranteed to have priority or be timely.

    what they expect? they let the ...Anonymous -- 08/01/05

    what they expect? they let their governments spy on them (after all they need to store all those sms) and dont do anything about it...

    they deserve what they get...the delays is probably because the tracking servers couldnt keep up with the load...

    and if smses become less and less reliable....thank God

    after all apathetic imberciles deserve nothing more

    I also had a problem with mess ...Anonymous -- 08/01/05

    I also had a problem with messaging, not so much on the international scale of the article, but also from local carriers.

    Me (Vodafone) , I couldn't send a message out from 12am till 2:30am... it was ridiculous, 2 hours and a half later i was replying to people who had messaged me, it was a joke, last year i could message people but had a few delays, but not hours completely.

    This year.. apparently upgrades were going to be made to the lines and what ends up happening? WORSE!!! I have to wait 2.5 hours...

    Its a joke... we are too behind in technology!

    Mario C.

    mcor82@yahoo.com.au

    I always have delays of about ...Anonymous -- 09/01/05

    I always have delays of about 30mins - 1hr every year during New Year's Eve. This year, I waited until 12.20am to be able to send my text message. I just thought this was acceptable, but reading this article, I guess not.

    Oh by the way, all my messages were within Australia to optus customers.

    In Vanuatu, SMS is ALWAYS that ...Anonymous -- 13/01/05

    In Vanuatu, SMS is ALWAYS that slow ; you can expect an SMS to take 1 to 2 days to arrive (to a local phone, too). If you're exceptionally lucky, it will only be 5-6 hours. I would love to know how this can happen - where are they stored? What is delaying them?? Such is life under a monopoly.

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Suzanne Tindal Sick of broken tender sites
    Some of the state governments desperately need to invest in more user-friendly tender sites so that looking for information on government tenders doesn't have to be a game of blind man's bluff.
  • Array Cyberwar: What is it good for?
    In this week's episode, Cyberwar. What is Australia's place in the world of digital warfare? What are the implications for the NBN?
  • Array Is wholesale-only backhaul just a pipedream?
    The potential acquisition of Pipe Networks by SP Telemedia has raised the question about whether vertically integrated backhaul providers will mean higher wholesale prices for ISP customers.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured