Telstra's $10 million broadband offering 'feeble' - Lundy

The Federal Opposition has branded Telstra's recent announcement of a AU$10 million boost to rural and regional broadband as nothing more than a feeble publicity stunt.

Senator Kate Lundy, the Shadow Minister for Information Technology, questioned Telstra during Senate Estimates Committee hearing as to the breakdown of the figure.

"After questioning Telstra in Senate Estimates, I discovered that the paltry offering is scarcely more than a publicity stunt consisting of a mixture of rebadged and inadequately funded projects," said Lundy.

Half of the AU$10 million came from projects that have previously been announced, such as AU$3 million for the upgrade of 100 exchanges to be ADSL enabled and AU$2 million pledged for making Remote Integrated Multiplexes (RIMs) compatible with ADSL.

"Another $1 million will be spent on transferring customers to alternative copper pathways, a trifling amount considering the 1.3 million pair gains services in the network," continued Lundy. "This would equate to an expenditure of less than a dollar for every one of the million or so Australians currently burdened with line splitting (pair gain) technology."

Senator Lundy went on to claim that a privatised Telstra would not spend the money required to provide regional Australians with an up-to-date telecommunications network, continuing the Oppositions fight against a sale of the rest of Telstra. While some media reports indicate the sale may be planned for early next year, other industry pundits argue the Federal Government would be stupid to sell its remaining Telstra share while the price is so low.

Talkback 6 comments

    In view of the huge profits Te ...Anonymous -- 22/11/02

    In view of the huge profits Telstra are making, $10 million would probably not even show up on the budget. How about making a commitment not a joke!

    The Mad Hatters in the T(H)els ...Keith Styles (A very,very disgruntled user) -- 22/11/02

    The Mad Hatters in the T(H)elstra Marketing Dept., couldn't organise a cook raffle. What ever happened to honesty & integrity. Do they think they are dealing with a community of morons? The duplicitity & blatant dishonesty is disgusting. When is senior management going to replace the idiot management they allow to run the shambles.
    A mention of T(H)elstra's ROI in ISND & the PSTN was made recently when a comparision to the cost of infastructure investment for broadband was being considered.
    Why make the comparision at all? Both technologies (ISDN & PSTN) are OLD technologies. If T(H)elstra hasn't recovered its costs by now, they never will. A business manager would be no better than the ludites at T(H)elstra if they do not replace their ISDN & PSTN services with Broadband. The cost savings and improvements in productivity are substantial. The private sector is unfortunately so disadvantaged by the costs imposed by T(H)elstra, they may never realize the full potential of broadband. They simply cannot afford the ridiculous prices imposed on them. Once again the Mad Hatters cannot do simple arithmetic. 100% of nothing is ZERO. An overpriced product simple will not reach its target market.

    Nothing negative about Telstra ...John Wayne -- 22/11/02

    Nothing negative about Telstra surprises me at all - in fact I wonder what is up when there is none of the usual bad news , as if they have found a new and improved way to lie and keep us in the dark.

    Telstra's motives are clear: b ...Anonymous -- 25/11/02

    Telstra's motives are clear: buy off the bush.

    The ABC's Media Watch (see http://www.abc.net.au/mediawatch/transcripts/071002_s2.htm) examined Telstra's Farmhand Foundation charity and the Water Australia initiative and reported the following people were the principal players behind Farmhand:

    "The Chairman is the Chairman of Telstra, Bob Mansfield. Its principals are John Hartigan the CEO of News Ltd, Telstra's partner in Foxtel.
    Kerry Packer the owner of Nine, Telstra's other partner in Foxtel. Sam Chisholm, chairman of Foxtel itself and Telstra director. Then ad man John Singleton, whose agency represents Telstra and who owns a share of 2GB, alongside Alan Jones, who is chief spokesman for Farmhand and whose breakfast show is sponsored by Telstra."

    Who are they kidding?

    I have applied for ADSL and wa ...Anonymous -- 06/06/03

    I have applied for ADSL and was not accepted. I am on a pair-gain network. I live at 15 minutes south of Brisbane CBD at Forest Lake, QLD 4078. A comunity that has grown from a population of 12,000 to 17,000 within the past 2 years. I have been waiting for ADSL for the past 5 years and still nothing.

    I read last week the following ..... "In May we began a process where if customer contacts Telstra and they can't access ADSL we will investigate if we can provide an alternative solution or achieve a work-around," said Lawrence.

    So, please consider this email as contact. I have again emailed Tel$tra today!

    I had been a loyal telstra cus ...Anonymous -- 02/09/03

    I had been a loyal telstra customer for 30 years and just recently changed all my accounts to optus.
    The reason?
    Telstra refused to change my Ant 1 system back to a copper connection.
    They originally sucked me into this system with a special offer that they had at the time so I let them install this Ant 1 system in my house so I could have a separate line for my fax machine.
    At no time did they let me know that I couldn't get it changed back.
    I have spoken to them on many occassions and they refuse to change it back.
    The telstra line tech's that I have had to my home have even gone to the local exchange and then told me it was a 10 minute job to fix the problem.
    Again telstra refused to allow the change back to the original line.
    I have since found out that a friend of mine has had the same problem's and frustration as I have with this horrible system.
    Can anyone help me solve this problem?
    Eric

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

Tags

Back to top

Featured