Telstra: Separation can be win-win

Telstra chief financial officer John Stanhope has said, subject to three key conditions, structural separation could benefit shareholders during the telco's Investor Day held in Sydney today.

The first condition Telstra wants met before it can sell the concept to its shareholders is that the government gives a "fair valuation" of assets that Telstra might vend-in to the NBN Co.

"The government's explanation sets out two broad forms of structural separation: the sale of the unbundled local loop (ULL fixed assets) or an agreed migration of our customers to NBN Co's fibre-to-the-premises network. In each case, Telstra's assets would be reduced. And shareholders would need to be made whole with some form of financial consideration," said Stanhope.

Stanhope said a successful negotiation with the government would be contingent on Telstra's separation undertaking not being overturned by a government minister or the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC).

A third condition would be that Telstra retain its stake in Foxtel, continue to hold its Hybrid Coaxial Fibre assets, and that the telco could bid for future wireless spectrum.

"If these conditions are met, structural separation appears to be a win-win for shareholders, the NBN Co, the government and the nation," said Stanhope.

In contrast to structural separation, the telco's CFO said the proposed functional separation of Telstra, which in the government's current proposal would see heavy oversight by the ACCC, would mean it would face a long period of being "inwardly focused". This separation structure would also work against the government, which faced time constraints, said Stanhope.

Despite Telstra's assurance that it would be able to strike a deal with the government, Telstra CEO David Thodey highlighted some of the hurdles it would face under the two proposed models for transferring power to the NBN Co.

Exactly what Telstra does with its copper network was too early to say, said Thodey. Key factors to consider were its universal service obligation (USO), priority assistance, and the proposed migration strategies: either to push Telstra's customers to the NBN Co or simply sells its ULL network to the NBN Co.

"The easiest way to do this is as you put the fibre in, you pull copper out," said Thodey. However, he noted there was still uncertainty within the government over what would happen to Telstra's copper network in rural areas. Telstra currently is obliged to provide phone services, but under the NBN these areas would be serviced via satellite or wireless.

One thing was certain though, according to Stanhope: "There will be a depreciation of Telstra's copper assets."

Advertisement

Talkback 10 comments

    Win win, eh? RS -- 28/10/09

    Hey Sydney...

    A while back you asked "where is this win-win Conroy promised"?

    Well here it is and it's from your CFO!

    Sit down Sydney, no need to salute him. No sit Sydney, don't kneel, lol!

    Maybe, maybe not. Sydney Lawrence -- 28/10/09 (in reply to #320389908)

    Hi RS and yes we hope for a win,win.

    As you are aware, and have stated, this suggestion comes from Telstra and I await response from Senator Conroy before I break out the Crown Lager.

    Me too. RS -- 28/10/09 (in reply to #320389926)

    Perhaps I'll join you in a Crownie Sydney?

    Because although one day you say I'm undeniably truthful and the next a nut case, "most of the time" I can have a friendly laugh and some banter with you Sydney, even though we have opposing views.

    Unlike Mike who really is odd, with his childish tongue poking, daily strangeness.

    You know he's actually an Optus customer, who says he's only with Optus because they are better value, what do you make of that? Telling someone they are a moron for not supporting Telstra but being an Optus customer himself, with dare I say, his profits going overseas, odd!

    Especially odd considering the other two Telstra protectors, both you and Vasso, are so 100% Telstra through and through!

    Anyway Sydney, enjoy your Crownie and have one for me (p.s. I almost bought in today, as I see things improving for Telstra, but...) lol!

    Let's make it very painful Anonymous -- 28/10/09 (in reply to #320389929)

    I am not so charitable. I just hope this separation hurts Telstra on many levels. It's such a hateable company that it deserves everything coming its way.

    Re Let's make it very painfil Sydney Lawrence -- 29/10/09 (in reply to #320389943)

    How sad Anonymous that you are so devoid of argument that you descend to idiotic levels of hate. Fear and jealousy are terrible masters.

    Telstra supporter #3 RS -- 29/10/09 (in reply to #320390004)

    No mention of Telstra supporter/shareholder #3 being an Optus customer Sydney?

    Please, I'd like to hear your thoughts.

    Is it ok for him to do that?
    Is he still a true believer?
    Still a legitimate member of the cause?
    Or is he a traitor?
    Hypocrite?
    or?

    What do you think Sydney?

    Read your history RS. Sydney Lawrence -- 29/10/09 (in reply to #320390006)

    RS you still don't get it.

    How many good Australians have to die in battle protecting peoples ability to choose in unfettered freedom what path they will take in life, before you see the light.

    That is why I am so disappointed that an Australian Government uses and condones blackmail to force the destruction of a great Australian company, to support a Government owned monopoly.

    They didn't die in battle for your wife's shares! RS -- 29/10/09 (in reply to #320390038)

    Can you get any lower Sydney?

    Perhaps you should have stopped at just one Crownie!

    RS, Chameleon extraordinaire Anonymous -- 01/11/09 (in reply to #320390073)

    You are unbelievable RS. Your behaviour and attitude changes at the absolute drop of a hat. What does not change however, is your rank hypocrisy, which is why you should be pitied and not prodded. You exhibit all the symptoms of a crazed dog.

    Oh Mike, lol RS -- 01/11/09 (in reply to #320390310)

    There once was a greedy fool... named Ne wIn

    Stupidly thought Telstra shares a shoe-in

    "If you knew what I paid you'd cry"

    Was his repetitive lie

    This clown...doesn't know what he's doin'

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Suzanne Tindal Sick of broken tender sites
    Some of the state governments desperately need to invest in more user-friendly tender sites so that looking for information on government tenders doesn't have to be a game of blind man's bluff.
  • Array Cyberwar: What is it good for?
    In this week's episode, Cyberwar. What is Australia's place in the world of digital warfare? What are the implications for the NBN?
  • Array Is wholesale-only backhaul just a pipedream?
    The potential acquisition of Pipe Networks by SP Telemedia has raised the question about whether vertically integrated backhaul providers will mean higher wholesale prices for ISP customers.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured