Telstra, Optus must give network data to FTTN rivals

Broadband Minister Senator Stephen Conroy has demanded that Telstra -- and a series of other carriers -- provide him with the physical details of their networks, in order to enlighten companies that may be interested in building the government's proposed fibre-to-the-node network.

The Minister sent a letter to the telcos this week requesting the information, which includes the length and location of cables. Conroy said the information should be returned by 3 March.

"We have written to all telecommunications network operators to ask them to provide information we believe is vital to ensure we have a genuine competitive bid process," Senator Conroy said in a statement.

In the event that the telcos in question do not provide the information that Conroy is seeking, it is understood the government could press ahead with legislation in order to force their hand.

A Telstra spokesperson said the telco intends to co-operate with the Minister and provide the data in question.

"In the interests of progressing the FTTN network that Australia needs, we want to provide the government with the information it seeks," the spokesperson said.

"In fact the detail embedded in this request -- unprecedented in Australia -- is also without precedent in overseas markets. Consider, for example, Singapore, where an FTTN tender is underway -- and SingTel is not being asked to divulge commercially sensitive information or law enforcement-related information either to the government or to competitors."

Telstra added it believes the detail required could potentially be a threat to national security and law enforcement.

Despite Telstra's concerns, the information collected is unlikely to be distributed wholesale to interested parties and it is believed that there would be access to the information set up through the Minister's office.

"The information that is being requested will be treated with utmost confidentiality. We recognise concerns about the sensitivity of information and will ensure those concerns are met," Conroy said.

Optus, the telco spearheading the rival G9 consortium which is also intending to tender for the FTTN network, said it has also received the letter from Senator Conroy.

"Optus will comply with the request outlined [by Conroy]," an Optus spokesperson said, adding that "issuing the letter is a strong pro-competition first move" in construction of the network.

Like this article? Click below to send it to your mobile for free!

Advertisement

Talkback 8 comments

  1. Eyes wide open Australia. Sydney Lawrence -- 01/03/08

    It is a surprise that Senator Conroy on behalf of the Rudd Government would request Telstra to reveal information to the public that could jeopardize the security of Australia and possibly give information to those who may wish to use such information to damage our security. Until the details (and Telstra’s reaction) are known it is difficult to sensibly comment further but the headline story in today’s Australian Newspaper February 29, “Foreign vultures eye ABC” was prophetic. The story explains in detail how the Singapore Government, through its Temasek Holdings is one of the biggest foreign investors in Australia. The article states “Industry experts said yesterday the sale of ABC childcare centres would see millions of dollars in Government subsidies flow out of Australia and on to the bottom line of overseas companies”. This is exactly the case with the billion dollar donation to Opel (Optus is owned by the Singapore Government) and it is to be hoped that Senator Conroy is awake to the damage that could be done to Australia should he not be extremely carefully in his application of possible damaging actions to Australia’s Telstra.

    1. Security Issue?? Nathan -- 02/03/08

      No offence but I don't see it as a major security implication. The documents will likely remain in house and confidential and lets face it, it doesn't require a genius to figure out where major fibre link cables are not to mention all exchanges aren't exactly hidden.

    2. 90%, 10% rule Hot 2 Trot -- 02/03/08

      90% of the general information is quite public and yes I drive past an exchange every day but to divulge the 10% that is not just a security concern but is also a commercial concern.

      This is a private company, the infrastructure which they "OWN" is no longer "OWNED" by the taxpayer and should not be forced to be shared as if it was.

      I can understand if the government requested information on the last 1/3 mile as this would be needed to build the FTTN network but to demand information beyond this is unrealistic.

      Whoever wins the final tender will be expected to dig up the streets and lay their own fiber to a local termination point in each area (probably around 10 from each exchange) and build their own junction box next to the Telstra unit. At this point they would need to jumper between them.

      To expect Telstra to provide access to their own infrastructure before the last 1/3 mile means the company building the network will just become another reseller of Telstra backbone and exchange infrastructure.

      In addition to this has anyone actually considered the existing capacity issues at many exchanges, there are companies can not get access to some exchanges for simple ADSL connectivity. What we are talking about here is much more equipment that will require more space, more power and more back end resources.

      Will Telstra be expected to foot the bill to upgrade power resources to these locations let alone another floor to cater for the room needed?

      This is a highly complex proposal that is being passed off to the public as a something as simple as flicking a few switches.

      All I hope is that Telstra does not get ripped to shreds during this process, it is after all our only truly national carrier.

    3. security... Anonymous -- 02/03/08

      if you're so scared of the Singapore government getting hold of the information, as it seems you are, maybe you'd be interested to know that Telstra does not own or operate ANY satellites, Optus owns 5, at least one of which is partially operated on behalf of the ADF, with Optus staff sitting right next to ADF staff in the Satellite operations centre...

    4. Defense Security Doctorate Hot 2 Trot -- 02/03/08

      Two factors.

      1. Telstra purchases bandwidth on third part satellites and carries web based traffic cross them. There is no access to satellites by Telstra or any other data that me be carried on them.

      2. The Optus staff who sit right next to the ADF staff in the satellite operations center have what is known as DSD security clearance, this is the highest level of security clearance a civilian can hold. Incoming and outgoing data is encrypted, the staff are scrutinised for criminal history as well as being checked on a regular basis for possible breaches of security.

      What we are talking about in the case of Telstra is handing over confidential information to a bunch of anonymous people who may sign a standard non disclosure agreement that in reality will not stop them if they wanted to share the information with anyone they want.

      You argument holds about as much water as my toilet and is made of the same substance that passes through it.

  2. Amazing Keep it secret, keep it safe -- 01/03/08

    What would happen if Holden was forced to release design details to ford or NASA to ESA etc?

    This is absolutely ludicrous, Rudd's speech at 200 days in office will go something like this ... I have done lots of wonderful things but due to the former government there are some I can't honor and by the way our military secrets have been given to the Indonesians as they have no idea how to run their own military. At 300 days he will announce all soldiers will now report to the Indonesian government and at 400 days he will announce as they killed all our soldiers we will be giving them $50 Billion dollars to rebuild.

    Telstra hands over network secrets and next thing you know they will hand over the copper and finally pour money into infrastructure destroyed because everyone simply took the bits they wanted.

    1. I am not attacking Indonesia in any way Keep it secret, keep it safe -- 01/03/08

      I simply used them as an example and could have chosen NZ or Ireland just as easily.

  3. Look at the disparity between opinions Anonymous -- 03/03/08

    Quoted from another online publication this morning

    ........ Australia Defence Association executive director Neil James echoed Telstra's concerns about the sensitive nature of the material and urged Senator Conroy to proceed cautiously. "There are obviously defence and wider national security implications - this isn't just a case of commercial-in-confidence information" also "We hope Senator Conroy has thought through the full implications of what he is asking."

    David Forman, executive director of the Competitive Carriers Coalition, said Telstra was raising the issue of national security in an effort to avoid releasing the material. "It is crucial Telstra is not allowed to use phoney reasons such as national security to avoid making any of this crucial data available," he said. "Telstra has flown the national security kite before, and it is simply laughable." .........

    One of the two people above only has the nations best interests in mind while the other openly campaigns for the demise of Telstra and represents a community who's prime focus is to find ways to help Telstra's competitors. We are all free to make our own judgement, I know who to support in this case.

Add your opinion


Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Renai LeMay MyPerfect.com.au has potential
    Victorian Web start-up My Perfect has a strong story and rationale for why it will succeed. But it has to overcome some challenges and design flaws first.
  • Array Storage infrastructure on the tender track
    For a large-scale storage project, it's not uncommon to go out to tender for the best deal — but when was the last time you had to put together a tender for a document management room?
  • Array Apple has killed the video store; will ISPs be next?
    The Olympics are nearly over, and the Australian team deserves kudos for an excellent performance all around. Yet even as the Olympic sun sets on the Bird's Nest for the last time this weekend, millions of spectators around the world will be scanning their dials in the hope of finding something else to fill their viewing hours.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured