Privacy advocates decry "fishing" expedition

The NSW Council for Civil Liberties has joined student associations to campaign against the music industry's attempts to gain access to personal information in its fight against music piracy.

Sony, EMI and Universal have taken Melbourne University, Sydney University and the University of Tasmania to court in a bid to gain access to files which may contain evidence of music piracy.

Council president Cameron Murphy told ZDNet Australia   the music industry was attempting to force the universities to ignore their obligations towards protecting the privacy of employees and students.

The council, together with the Council of Australian Postgraduate Associations and Sydney Universities Postgraduates Representative Association, will conduct a campaign to prevent the varsities from providing personal information requested by the music industry.

According to Murphy, there are two main aspects to the campaign. "We're informing people about the case because they are unaware as to what's going on and, more importantly, are unaware of the consequences to privacy as a result of this case," said Murphy. "The second aspect is to ensure universities fulfil their obligations in terms of privacy to students and staff."

"Of course [the music industry] has a right to protect its intellectual property rights but this is not the way to do it...people should only be acting if there's evidence of wrongdoing," said Murphy. He said the music companies were attempting to fish through the information to see if there were any copyright breaches.

In court last Friday the universities argued the music companies were seeking a "search for the purpose of discovery rather than a search as a result of discovery". They argued that the backup reel the music companies were seeking access to contained information other than that sought by the companies, and the companies should therefore dictate which particular files they deemed relevant.

The music companies argued that the entire backup reel constituted a document, and that it contained evidence relevant to the case. "The fact that it includes other documents doesn't mean it ceases to contain evidence that is relevant," said the lawyer for the music industry. "The [reel] relates to the relevant issue. The fact that it also relates to other issues is neither here nor there."

Until the judgement on the case is handed down, it is unclear how much of an impact it will have on issues such as privacy and copyright protection in Australia.

Advertisement

Talkback 5 comments

    How is it that Universities se ...Anonymous -- 14/04/03

    How is it that Universities seem to be teaching their students that it is OK to break the law? A recent comment that "civil libertarians protect the guilty and damn the innocent" seems to ring true here.

    Get over it Barry. Do you rea ...Anonymous -- 14/04/03

    Get over it Barry. Do you really think that it's fair that the music industry are claiming that one breach of their copyright gives them the right to access the entire network backup for the university system. Even if there were 10, 100 or 1000 breaches, then releasing this information is sure to breach the privacy of those that use the university networks and did not commit a crime. What sort of company tries to sue students??? How the f#@k are they supposed to be responsible for loss of profit when they wouldn't be able to afford the legitimate purchase of the music in the first place? The music industry have no interest but to increase their profits at the expense of fair use and common sense. They are one of a multitude of corporate leeches on modern society.

    Hi Jason. I didn't mean that ...Anonymous -- 14/04/03

    Hi Jason. I didn't mean that students should be sued, but that they should obey the law. I run my own company and have to buy legitimate software (like the stuff you write maybe). If I can't afford it, I do WITHOUT it. Merely wanting it does not mean I should steal it. Why can't people do without instead of adding to the costs of doing business (my cost of software and music goes up if this continues) Perhaps UNIs should limit what students get up to?

    Everyone knows universities ar ...Anonymous -- 15/04/03

    Everyone knows universities are breeding grounds for illegal distribution of MP3 files and warez.

    It's high time they were taken to task. They cannot bury their heads in the sand any longer.

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • David Braue Can not-so-smart meters help the NBN?
    It was interesting to witness Conroy's recent enthusiasm to spruik the NBN's role in supporting the Smart Grid, Smart City initiative. What a pity that Conroy hadn't yet seen the damning report from the Victorian auditor-general about that state's smart-meter roll-out.
  • Array Can the Telco Reform Act be win-win?
    In the second of our two programs looking at the Senate Inquiry into the Telecommunications Legislation Amendment Bill, we hear from shareholders, bureaucrats and industry groups.
  • Array Has New Zealand's smiling assassin delivered?
    One year into its tenure, how has the new New Zealand Government performed on issues of technology and telecommunications?
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured