Department scrutinises Optus' 3G

The bad press surrounding Optus' 3G mobile network problems has caused the federal broadband department to investigate whether or not its network and that of Vodafone qualify as real broadband in terms of government subsidies.

Simon Cobcroft speaking today
(Credit: Suzanne Tindal/ZDNet.com.au)

The Department of Broadband, Communications and the Digital Economy had needed to determine whether or not those using the network had "metro-comparable" broadband access, acting assistant secretary Simon Cobcroft told the Broadband World conference in Sydney today.

"On paper at least they seem to be offering metro-comparable services, to, when they're fully deployed, up to 98 per cent of the country," he said.

If this were the case, anyone in range wouldn't be able to apply for the government subsidy, because a metro-comparable service would be available from a commercial operator.

However, Cobcroft wasn't sure that the services matched up to the operators' claims. "We really want to make sure that, because there's been a lot of press about the quality of the services on that network, to make sure that that network is robust — those networks are robust," he said.

Cobcroft said the department had even delayed the deadline for internet service providers putting in applications for providing services in order to assess the coverage and performance.

Optus has born the brunt of bad press in recent months after experiencing some outages on its 3G network which Andrew Buay, Optus managing director of products and delivery recently said were due to its recent network expansion requiring frequent software upgrades which have not always been glitch-free.

The deadline passed on 31 October, however the department has not yet made the decision. "We're looking at that at the moment and I think probably only a few weeks away we'll make a determination on whether we consider those networks to be metro-comparable," Cobcroft said.

In an applications deadline update, the department did not mention the investigation into coverage being due to bad press, making it it seem more a routine process for carriers claiming to offer metro-comparable services.

In the update, the department said it had undertaken a detailed assessment of the coverage and performance of Optus and was continuing to work with the carrier "to resolve some outstanding matters". On Vodafone it said only that investigation had commenced.

Advertisement

Talkback 4 comments

    dial up comparable James O'sullivan -- 06/11/08

    Optus network has a tendency to switch back to 2g mode about 50 times a day. I might add this is when phone is showing FULL reception. Thought it might be a phone problem but i tried it on all 3 of my 3g capable phones and one of my mates nokia 6120's and still the same crap. The real question is " is optus' 3g network dial up comparable"

    dial up comparable? Paul Grenfell -- 06/11/08 (in reply to #320115646)

    Thats the problem identified.!!. Set your device to "3g only" That should solve the problem..Thats a device setting glitch, not a network glitch.

    dial up comparable Anonymous -- 07/11/08

    Unless metro broadband plans are selling you a couple of gig of data for $30-50 then I don't think there really can be a comparison made between the two. If you aren't in a metro area you'll still be disadvantaged. And the subsidy is still needed

    still dial up comparable Anonymous -- 09/11/08

    I changed the settings to umts/3g only on my nokia 6120. it stays on 3g but then optus' network decides to crash and go back on 2g several times a day instead of having 2g i now get no service. i get full reception in the area im in too. I'm glad i got a next g sim card to use when i want to browse the net for movie times/emails. Telstra might cost more but at least it works 99.999% of the time. actually the only time i didn't get service was when i was in some huge forest/mountain in tassie.

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Blogs

  • Darren Greenwood Telecom NZ savings damage prospects
    If Telecom NZ wants to have any of the NZ$1.5 billion the government intends to spend on its new broadband network, it had better think long and hard before offshoring 1500 jobs.
  • Array iiNet: The whys and what nows
    Last week the Federal Court ruled that internet service providers are not responsible for copyright violation by their customers. This is an important decision not just for iiNet, which spent around $4 million defending the case, but for all ISPs in Australia and, indeed, globally.
  • Array Govt, hurry up with releasing data
    A programmer scraped data from the My School website to make some really cool heat maps showing regions of smart schools — no thanks to the government, which didn't supply the data in any useful kind of format.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured