Criticism greets Howard's broadband plans

Australian Prime Minister John Howard has officially opened the World Congress on IT, using the address to forshadow a major announcement regarding Australia's broadband infrastructure.

-We are conscious that the provision of broadband is an important to Australia, and are interested in revealing the ways we can harness broadband to reap the dividends for all Australians," Howard said.

WCIT 2002 Special Coverage He went on to announce the formation of a joint government and industry group set to be chaired by Federal IT Minister, Senator Richard Alston, which will be created to ensure the benefits of IT are captured by the bulk of Australians.

The Prime Minister's comments have been attacked by Shadow Minister for Information Technology, Senator Kate Lundy, who said the announcements regarding broadband fly in the face of comments made by Alston during the recent election campaign.

-It is ironic that today's announcement contradicts the Senator's comments during the election campaign that broadband was not a key driver in the information economy," Lundy said. -Both of the initiaves are ideas directly pilphered from the Labor party's Knowledge Nation policies and in that sense the Coalition is again playing catch-up when it comes to IT policies."

Lundy also critiscised the Prime Minister's focus on Australia as a consumer rather than a producer of technology.

-It goes to show that the coalition still doesn't get it when it comes to technology," Lundy said.

Howard also used the event to reaffirm Australian's commitment to the US in its war on terrorism, and critisise the Eurpoean Union for its agricultural tariff policies. In fact he spent the bulk of the address covering Australia's agricultural and mining industries, commenting briefly on how IT had improved productivity across all sectors of the economy.

-We now export more wine to the UK, than the French, which says something about our excellent wine industry," he said, apparently forgetting the focus of the congress is information technology.

Advertisement

Talkback 12 comments

    Go Johnny! Put in your 2cents ...the saint -- 27/02/02

    Go Johnny! Put in your 2cents worth. Not that we care. We could have had broadband a couple of years ago, but NOOO.. The PM thinks cabling is 'unsightly'. Funny how he has to use an IT Convention to justify his action regarding Terrorism & Aust. Exports. Get off your soap-box Johnny, we don't care. And go Telstra - Charge us Joes Hundreds of $$ for a BB/ADSL connection, and set up new wiring with pair-gains (ie crap) - What are they thinking? ($$$$) Broadband is the future, yet its inaccessible to 98% of us. Wake up Johnny!

    What a crock. About 3 years to ...Anonymous -- 27/02/02

    What a crock. About 3 years to late to jump on the bankwagon now. The major problem is Telstra and Alstons inability to grasp Broadband, and IT for that matter.
    Why set up another committee just to tell you that we are too late. If you hopped on the web and had a look you can see sites all over the world bagging Telstra and Australia's broadband policy. Perhaps neither Mr Howard or Mr Alston know how to surf the internet!
    Just another waste of our money...again.

    More like unconscious. The bum ...Anonymous -- 27/02/02

    More like unconscious. The bumbling efforts to raise the price of Telstra (preserving their monopoly and ludicrous pricing) at the expence of Australias IT future is disgusting. Why little jonny howard was even allowed to attend the conference let alone speak is unbelieveable (more distortions of the truth and some pathetic poltical bs)

    John Howard, you are an embarr ...Anonymous -- 27/02/02

    John Howard, you are an embarrasment of a Prime Minister. Hurry up and retire like you said you would. You are way past your use-by date.

    As always, little johnny howar ...Anonymous -- 27/02/02

    As always, little johnny howard is stuck in the past. I hope one day we could have a prime minister who looks into the future and prepares australia for what has not yet happened, rather than taking a reactive approach to everything. Howard is a sad little man who won the election on propaganda, not real policy or commitment to australia's future.
    Why do we have these people running our country. It's a sad reflection of the voting public.

    Bah... Appoint a (luddite) Tel ...Anonymous -- 27/02/02

    Bah... Appoint a (luddite) Tel$tra puppet to head a committee to help broadband. What a joke. And the sad thing is he announced this to the cream of the IT world.

    The whole thing almost makes me embarrassed to be Australian.

    Too bad little Johnny, you missed the boat. Maybe the illegal immigrants should have thrown you over board.

    My sentiments on this matter a ...Rolf Harris -- 27/02/02

    My sentiments on this matter appear to be very much like those of others who have submitted feedback.

    As Australians all of us know other Australians and in general I believe they are innovative and very much in favour of making changes where changes should and need to be made , and I have always felt we have a lot to offer globally and evidence of that is the way people outside of Australia seem to react to us and hire us abroad.

    Unfortunately , we are in a country where the government has as much backbone as a jellyfish and the knowledge of my cat Fluffy when it comes to communications and IT technology. I still remember our communications ministers comments on broadband , and how it has droolworthy status amongst gamers who ain't out of puberty yet.

    Quite often as an Aussie I feel great embarrassment over our politicians and the policies set by them , especially when they are so off base regarding issues which are affected by these policies. I often wonder how this country stays above sea level as with the minds we have in Canberra , its a wonder they ain't selling the sand on our foreshores overseas to countries with black and grey sand.

    Its said to see how our IT ind ...Anonymous -- 27/02/02

    Its said to see how our IT industry is been handycapped by the short sightedness of our politicans. They might have law degrees (most of them) but they don't understand IT or broadband for that matter.

    Get Kerry O'Brian from the ABC ...Anonymous -- 28/02/02

    Get Kerry O'Brian from the ABC's 7.30 report to interview Richard "Luddite" Alston, and make this the first question: As communications minister, at the helm, do you think that setting up inquires about the impact of broadband on the future of Australian IT is a bit late?....

    Then ask him: Do we REALLY need government bodies, when already Australia is clearly behind Asia, some of Europe, and now Britain, in the uptake of broadband?.....

    Then Finally: Why did organisations such as TUG, and other Broadband related companys, such as our very own incumbent carrier Telstra, only just hear of this plan, which just happened to be announced at the World IT conference?...

    "He went on to announce t ...Will Nitschke -- 28/02/02

    "He went on to announce the formation of a joint government and industry group set to be chaired by Federal IT Minister, Senator Richard Alston, which will be created to ensure the benefits of IT are captured by the bulk of Australians."

    Unfortunately, Richard Alston is the same clown who banned the development of streaming video delivery services in Australia because it would conflict with the vested interests of the big television stations.

    As well, if the opposition actually cared or understood the issues they could have blocked that legislation with the support of the Democrates & Greens (who actually understood the implications and opposed it). They can't have it both ways. Both political parties are corrupt, or maybe just inept, to the determiment of all Australians. It's the best case going for voting independant...

    The Oz Conundrum... If Telstra ...Anonymous -- 28/02/02

    The Oz Conundrum...

    If Telstra were truly independent AND open to competition, then market forces might have delivered us Broadband in Oz by now and polititians would not be grandstanding on this and other IT issues that they don't really understand.
    But as Telstra creeps inexorably towards full privatisation, so it seems that services get more expensive and thinner on the ground.
    Broadband need a real kickstart - Mr. Howard, TELL Telstra to make broadband more accessible and let's get back in the race.

    Too bad they still have not go ...Anonymous -- 28/02/02

    Too bad they still have not got it (IT!) and it shows.
    The world's investors are voting with their feet. This countrie's leaders need to realise that Bauxite (that we send to the Japanese -who then send it back as cars and other high priced consumer goods) and upper class plonk (sent to England) is not the type of economic activity that the worlds investors value). It could be surmised that the reason why our dollar is now jokingly referred to as the "Pacific Paso" is because of the total lack of understanding or willingness to peruse and support the IT sector in this country (not as a consumer, but as a producer!). Hey Jonny! Remember the $$$ you love so much! Here is a little hint on how to improve our national economy (OK 2 little hints) education (a PUBLIC good - not private one) and support for the IT industry. Look at Ireland - 10 years of solid support of the education sector and an emphasis on IT has produced a powerhouse economy in a country better known in the past as net exporter of its population than for IT development (now they can't get enough IT people to meet their demand). Maybe its because our government lives in the past, maybe they have plenty of poor advice, maybe its because they have too many political imperatives that lead them to ignore good advice. Who knows, but one thing is for certain, until they get their act together, out A$ - err Pacafic Paso - will remain in the doldrums.

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Suzanne Tindal Sick of broken tender sites
    Some of the state governments desperately need to invest in more user-friendly tender sites so that looking for information on government tenders doesn't have to be a game of blind man's bluff.
  • Array Cyberwar: What is it good for?
    In this week's episode, Cyberwar. What is Australia's place in the world of digital warfare? What are the implications for the NBN?
  • Array Is wholesale-only backhaul just a pipedream?
    The potential acquisition of Pipe Networks by SP Telemedia has raised the question about whether vertically integrated backhaul providers will mean higher wholesale prices for ISP customers.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured