Conroy's dept refuses NBN FOI

Stephen Conroy's Department of Broadband, Communications and the Digital Economy has refused the iiNet-backed Tech Wired Australia request to access the expert panel's recommendations on the National Broadband Network bids using freedom of information laws.

The department sent a 17-page document to Tech Wired, listing its reasons for refusing the request, which in summarised form added up to the panel's report being exempt under sections 34 and 36 of the Freedom of Information Act.

The exemption was based on the report being a document which was made for the purposes of Cabinet consideration and that it wasn't in the public's interest to disclose it since the factors against disclosure of the report outweighed the factors in favour of disclosure of the report.

Tech Wired had already paid a deposit of $908 to access the report. The total costs of obtaining the documents would have been $3,631.99, according to the department, based on the work which would have been involved in processing the request.

iiNet had volunteered to bankroll Tech Wired's Freedom of Information request because the government had promised that the competitive assessment process would be open and transparent, with opportunities for industry and community input.

The condition of iiNet's funding was that Tech Wired publish the documents.

Advertisement

Talkback 13 comments

    Thanks Sol Anonymous -- 17/03/09

    Maybe all will be revealed on some future Oprah Winfrey show.

    In the meantime Australia wilts because it can't move forward fast enough, thanks for that Sol, I'm sure we will find your explanation for this on the back of some share offer prospectus.

    WTF? You are an Arse Sol -- 17/03/09 (in reply to #320125912)

    How does this story get twisted to a T bashing exercise? The fact the NBN is even on the agenda is because Telstra made an offer to the former government which was rejected and the current government stole the idea, increased the cost by 3 times and claim it all as their own. If current and former governments made it attractive for companies to invest in this country they we might be in a better position. From what I see there are over 700 other registered telcos who could invest but have chosen not to.

    rofl @ transparent Mel Sommersberg -- 17/03/09

    "iiNet had volunteered to bankroll Tech Wired's Freedom of Information request because the government had promised that the competitive assessment process would be open and transparent, with opportunities for industry and community input."

    HA HA HA HA HA HA.

    The Labor Party is about as transparent as Ayers Rock.

    Re rofl Anonymous -- 17/03/09 (in reply to #320125915)

    Bit like when the previous cu**servative government refused to allow perusal of the winning OPEL docs. But that was ok wasn't it.

    Good to see as always, you'll tell half the story and NEVER let the facts cloud your bs, hey Mr S.

    So speaking of HA HA HA HA.

    what?? Glenn -- 17/03/09 (in reply to #320125930)

    Actually I'm not sure if you read the article but Opel wasn't brought up anywhere. It's true that both govenments haven't been as transparent as they should be but I don't think there's a bias reason for keeping Opel quiet; it just didn't come up...

    Never let anonymous BS cloud one's judgement Mel Sommersberg -- 18/03/09 (in reply to #320125930)

    Whilst Opel is irrelevant, Opel was actually delivered as a going concern. A plan was put in place, tenders called for, a tender was then selected and a contract signed. Three months later we had an election. Once KRudd took over from Mr Howard the Opel contract was torn up by the new regime - despite no hint of that plot coming during the election. So Mr Anonymous troll, your mate KRudd broke an election commitment to roll out fast broadband by 1. Scrapping the plans for a wireless network in rural areas and 2. stuffarsing around with the FTTN. Labor isn't committed to honouring election promises, well except the symbolistic ones that make them look good to the UN and Barack Obama. What matters to us seems to take a distant last place it seems.

    Gag Order Anonymous -- 17/03/09

    I think this whole issue of a Gag order is ridiculous.
    I didn't vote for you Stephen Conroy. I certainly don't trust you. I am inside the industry and don't work for Telstra. Lets forget the mess. We have fibre to the home in green field developments. If you really need high speed. People will move. Lets forget this stupid idea for a project and stop wasting tax payers money!

    Gag order needed above Anonymous -- 17/03/09 (in reply to #320125917)

    I didn't vote for you Stephen Conroy?

    Do you really expect anyone to take you seriously after that?

    Faith.. Reece -- 17/03/09

    "The Government of Australia is elected," he said. "If the parliament wants to take this path, the last time I checked, that's ok." Sen Conroy (talking about a different matter)

    That pretty much sums it up. Don't ask questions, this will only affect all Australians. It is only our tax dollers. Why should we have any view or say. Because Governments are almighty and know best. Conroy obviously has been working in the IT industry for along time so we can trust and have faith he is in the right position and has our best wishs at heart.
    I think you know where you can take your faith big guy.

    If they stuff the NBN up, and im sure they have the right qualifications to, it is us that will have to cop it. Stop being underhanded Conjob.. This is 2 for 2 so far.

    what experience? kevin -- 18/03/09 (in reply to #320125940)

    He never worked in the IT industry.

    yeah Anonymous -- 18/03/09 (in reply to #320125955)

    Google "sarcasm".

    Nice price. Stephen Conroy's Grandfather -- 18/03/09

    Luckily, Tech Wired should just about be able to recoup the $908 using Kevin Rudd's bailout.

    Conroy Anonymous -- 18/03/09

    Sen Conroy is a complete AssHat. This is so typical of this closed communication Government. Shame on Sen Conroy for not releasing the details. Perhaps he's afraid that the nation will finaly bring him to admit his faults:

    Unwilling to communicate with Industry.
    Unwilling to listen to public opinion.
    Unwilling to discuss in a resonable and debated manner issues and concerns of the General public.
    Unwilling to spend my Tax payer funds the way of the general majority.

    Sen. Conroy seems to be unwilling to openly debate the governments policies in a public forum. I wonder why?

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Suzanne Tindal Sick of broken tender sites
    Some of the state governments desperately need to invest in more user-friendly tender sites so that looking for information on government tenders doesn't have to be a game of blind man's bluff.
  • Array Cyberwar: What is it good for?
    In this week's episode, Cyberwar. What is Australia's place in the world of digital warfare? What are the implications for the NBN?
  • Array Is wholesale-only backhaul just a pipedream?
    The potential acquisition of Pipe Networks by SP Telemedia has raised the question about whether vertically integrated backhaul providers will mean higher wholesale prices for ISP customers.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured