Broadband snarled in political wrangle

Federal Minister for Communications and Information Technology, Daryl Williams has hit back at the Victorian ICT Minister for criticising the coalition government's contribution to regional broadband access.

Williams released a statement yesterday following comments made by Victorian minister, Marsha Thomson, saying that "while Ms Thomson is happy to welcome the Howard government's money into her State, her comments today demonstrate that she remains embarrassingly isolated and ignorant on broadband policy".

In a release issued yesterday, Thomson stated that the government has not provided rural Victorians with adequate access to broadband services, despite the region's increasing demand.

The state Minister referred to a report commissioned by the state government, "Spend/Demand - Telecommunications in Regional and Rural Victoria", claiming the government has only opted for ad hoc solutions for filling broadband black holes and that "real areas of need will continue to miss out".

"This report highlights that for many areas in Victoria demand is already strong enough to justify broadband supply," she said.

However, Williams has accused the Victorian minister of playing politics with broadband "rather than working with the Howard government to improve access to this important technology".

The federal Minister said that although his state counterpart was quick to criticise, she has failed to sign a National Broadband Strategy that Victorian officials helped to develop and her fellow state Labor colleagues have already signed.

According to the release the broadband strategy was specifically designed to improve broadband access for regional Australians.

Williams claims the Howard government is "actively spending" the AU$142.8 million it has allocated towards the scheme.

"It is ironic that Ms Thomson decided to launch her misguided attack on the same day I announced AU$2.8 million in funding for community-based broadband demand aggregation projects - including two in Victoria worth more than AU$550,000," Williams stated in the release.

Thomson also criticised the governments Higher Bandwidth Incentive Scheme (HiBIS), saying that it was an "ad hoc" solution, which may just turn out to be a "pork barreling exercise".

However, Williams said that many of the regions in demand for broadband that were mentioned in the state governments report will benefit from HiBIS.

"Contrary to Ms Thomson's claims, the HiBIS guidelines were developed only after extensive research into the broadband needs of rural and regional Australia," said the release.

Williams said he would also like to "remind Ms Thomson of two significant broadband projects recently funded by the Howard government in Victoria"; citing an AU$8 million rural health service in the Grampians and an AU$2 million health infrastructure project that it said "is improving broadband connectivity to more than 30 communities in North West Victoria".

Advertisement

Talkback 6 comments

    Victorian rural residents are ...Anonymous -- 07/07/04

    Victorian rural residents are not alone. This is a nationwide problem, country and city. I live in suburban Sydney and have been trying for over 18 months to get broadband with no solution in sight.

    A Federal Minister can always ...Anonymous -- 07/07/04

    A Federal Minister can always get his spin doctors to come up with what on the surface look like impresive spending figures on broadband but in reality the Howard government for years has failed to encurage and drive the roll out of Broadband into regional and rural Australia. John howards committment to IT in general was shown when he appointed Daryl Williams as its latest minister. Almost before he sat in his new ministerial chair he announced he would be retiring at the next election, so we have currently a lame duck IT minister.

    Daryl Williams has not even bo ...Anonymous -- 07/07/04

    Daryl Williams has not even bothered to acknowledge my emails over the sham that masquerades as ADSL coverage in WA... at least the victorian minister got his attention...

    If our state govt thinks that ...Anonymous -- 08/07/04

    If our state govt thinks that our Fed Govt has done nothing to address Broadband in our state, then what the heck HIBIS is?

    If the state minister is quick to dismiss HIBIS as pork barrelling, then what should Daryl Wlliams do so anything he does, would NOT be considered as pork barrelling?

    Dizzy Dazza doesn't have a clu ...Anonymous -- 08/07/04

    Dizzy Dazza doesn't have a clue what he's talking about.
    Nothing about Broadband happens unless T(H)elstra deploys the gear. But before that happens, wait for it!! T(H)elstra needs users to ask and then wait for the T(H)elstra DSLAMS to be ordered, requisitioned deployed and commissioned.
    The rual areas as well as many surban areas in all capital cities of Australia could wait for ever for this process to eventually, if ever, provide a service in their area. For a business to succeed, it has to get off it's lazy A*SE and go look for business, not wait for it to come in the door, before servicing the need.
    Wake up Dazza and T(H)elstra. We are becoming the backwater of HiTech.

    It doesn't have to be Telstra ...Anonymous -- 08/07/04

    It doesn't have to be Telstra (weird spelling you seem to have there Keith) that deploys broadband. Any of the global telecoms companies could do it via a variety of means. But will people be willing to pay for satellite, which is likely the only feasible way of getting broadband out to our regional areas? Probably not. As far as ADSL goes, (and it doesn't go that far:) ISP's are able to install their equipment into Telstra exchanges - why aren't they if there is such a high level of demand?

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Chris Duckett Get extensions going in Firefox, redux
    Previously on Null Pointer we looked at getting extensions working in Firefox betas, and that was great until the fine folks at Firefox changed their minds.
  • Array How reliable is IP telephony?
    Have you ever heard a weird kind of hissing, crackling or popping noise when calling someone on an IP telephony line? How rare is the phenomenon these days?
  • Array Forget the NBN, 100Mbps is already here
    Telstra and TransACT will shortly begin offering 100Mbps broadband to many customers. By moving early, the companies have not only raised the bar for Australia's broadband services, but thrown down a challenge to a government that now faces increased pressure to deliver the NBN as promised.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured