Australia not ready for the electronic ballot: AEC

Despite the apparent success of electronic voting in the ACT election on the weekend, the federal branch of the Australian Electoral Commission believes Australia is still a long way from digital voting.

Pointing to a series of technical and logistical difficulties, assistant commissioner for information and research at the AEC in Canberra Brian Hallett said, electronic voting would have to overcome some major hurdles before being introduced for Federal elections.

-It is definitely something we are very interested in, but it would need to win the support of the electorate and the parliament before being implemented at a federal level," Hallett said. -While a lot of our backend is already computerised, the logistics and costs associated with rolling out the appropriate technologies to over eight thousand polling places across Australia has to be considered."

Although Hallett is urging caution, he is also quick to point out the benefits of electronic voting systems, including a significantly shorter wait for votes to be counted and scrutinised.

According to Hallett the bar-code based technology used in the ACT election is only one of a number of different technologies being considered by the AEC.

However, it is not only the federal AEC taking the implementation of electronic voting slowly. The weekend's election saw only 9 percent of the electorate (or 19 000 voters) take advantage of the keyboard-and-screen system made available at pre-polling day electoral offices, according to a Computer Daily News report. While the technology showed some teething problems, with the wrist-flick needed to read the bar code a challenge for some voters, the locally developed software, and task-specific keyboards, may one day become a feature in polling booths across the country.

Talkback 10 comments

    I'm wondering what the electro ...Michelle Harris -- 22/10/01

    I'm wondering what the electronic ballot was like - did anyone in ACT who reads this use it? Do you have the ability to cast an informal vote using this method? Could you, for example, add your own box and vote for someone not nominated? Could you add comments?

    Just wondering - I know these are probably things that they're trying to reduce, but I think that you should still be able to do with an electronic vote what you can with a paper vote.

    What's the point using a compu ...Chris -- 22/10/01

    What's the point using a computer if you have to go to the polling booth anyway?

    We should be voting from our lounge-room.

    Spending money to impliment anything else is a waste of time, effort, and my tax dollars - particurlarly since it will get discarded when lounge-room-voting finally does get introduced eventually.

    There is a point in eVoting at ...Anonymous -- 22/10/01

    There is a point in eVoting at the polling booth - it would automate tallying.

    This would reduce the cost of employing people to manually count votes (several times over in cases such as Florida earlier this year)and would be able to produce a result almost instantly.

    Remote voting would be helpful, especially in remote areas and for absentee votes.

    Issues such as secret voting and proof of identity do need to be solved.

    I didn't use the e-ballot syst ...Anonymous -- 22/10/01

    I didn't use the e-ballot system, and by all accounts it needs some more work.

    In my opinion it would need a facility to make an informal vote.

    Also, there is an argument that voting away from a polling booth has the potential for coercion, but I suppose this also applied to postal voting.

    The title of this article shou ...Anonymous -- 23/10/01

    The title of this article should be "The AEC is not ready for the electronic ballot"

    I honestly wonder if the AEC has even heard of electricity sometimes. With their lame excuses and reasons for delaying electronic voting.

    1). As for security, there is little security now!
    2). Secrecy, claiming how will they know that a voter is not coerced into casting a particular vote. How do they deal with postal votes now?
    3). Cost of implementation. How much does it cost to print all those copies of the Electoral Rolls for every election? How much does it cost to count all those votes?
    4). It seems that the AEC think that to implement a new system they will need to dispense with the old completely. Bollocks! Further evidence that the AEC is still working with pen and paper.

    On the 29/06/2001
    http://www.zdnet.com.au/newstech/news/story/0,2000025345,20104973,00.htm
    And unnamed spokesperson for the AEC is quoted as saying "With start-up costs to consider, "it's not feasible at the moment," the spokesperson said. "Although online voting presents a user-friendly opportunity for those who are computer literate, not 100 percent of the Australian population are [computer literate], therefore there currently isn't a system to fit the Australian environment,"

    Come on 100% of the Australian population are not voting literate, does that mean that we should not have elections?

    As for the conclusion that "therefore there currently isn't a system to fit the Australian environment" using this conclusion there would never be a system that fitted the "Australian Environment" or anywhere in the world for that matter.

    computerised electoral system ...Anonymous -- 05/05/05

    computerised electoral system will curb electoral rigging if there is a software that will detect when one is of age limit and that one does not vote twice.

    computerised electoral system ...Anonymous -- 05/05/05

    computerised electoral system will curb electoral rigging if there is a software that will detect when one is of age limit and that one does not vote twice.

    computerised electoral system ...Anonymous -- 05/05/05

    computerised electoral system will curb electoral rigging if there is a software that can those who are not of age limit to vote and also to prevent multiple voting.

    computerised electoral system ...Anonymous -- 05/05/05

    computerised electoral system will curb electoral rigging if there is a software that can detect those who are not of age limit to vote and also to prevent multiple voting.

    computerised electoral system ...Anonymous -- 05/05/05

    computerised electoral system will curb electoral rigging if there is a software that can detect those who are not of age limit to vote and also to prevent multiple voting.

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

Tags

Back to top

Featured