NBN - Everything you need to know about the National Broadband Network

Auditor-General to probe NBN decision

Federal Auditor-General Ian McPhee has revealed he will conduct a preliminary review of Labor's terminated National Broadband Network tender process.

The Rudd Government wasted almost 18 months and $20 million on a tender which was based on totally unrealistic key objectives.

Nick Minchin

McPhee believed the review, to be conducted by the Australian National Audit Office (ANAO), would begin in mid-May when resources became available. ANAO has already sought the cooperation of the Department of Broadband, Communications and the Digital Economy for the review.

His decision to look into the tender followed his receipt of a letter by Shadow Communications Minister Nick Minchin last month asking for a review to be held on the tender, which Minchin considered to be "fundamentally flawed".

McPhee has written back to Minchin confirming the review, in a letter seen by ZDNet.com.au.

"The Rudd Government wasted almost 18 months and $20 million on a tender which was based on totally unrealistic key objectives, which the bidders themselves confirmed could not be met," Minchin said today in a statement.

The termination of the tender process was a surprise to the industry. One bidder's CEO, Ivan Slavich from TransACT, had expressed his dissatisfaction at the time, saying that his company's plan did meet the tender requirements. He believed the government should reimburse vendors for their troubles out of good faith.

Minchin has also been pushing for the release of the expert panel's advice, which would have been made publicly available after the selection of a winning bidder as directed by a Senate order. Since no winning bidder was announced, Communications Minister Stephen Conroy has not released the panel's advice, saying its information is commercial in confidence.

Advertisement

Talkback 6 comments

    Krudd and SPIN? Anonymous -- 06/05/09

    Who cares now!! with Krudd spin these days what can ypu believe???

    Telstra Win Anonymous -- 06/05/09

    A cursory view suggests Telstra were quite smart not to respond to the tender. Invariably they will be involved in whatever rollout may occur and I'm sure they knew this all along, they don't look so silly now. Not that I support the way this has been handled by the Govt, pretty cheap of them.

    Telstra win? Anonymous -- 06/05/09 (in reply to #320134906)

    So you say this was well played by Telstra all along?

    Telstra the Fox! Anonymous -- 06/05/09 (in reply to #320134907)

    .....the old fox

    Telstra win! Anonymous -- 06/05/09 (in reply to #320134907)

    Hehe, sure am. And in its position, only Telstra could afford to respond in this way.

    ha! Anonymous -- 07/05/09

    How much would this have costed?

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Suzanne Tindal Sick of broken tender sites
    Some of the state governments desperately need to invest in more user-friendly tender sites so that looking for information on government tenders doesn't have to be a game of blind man's bluff.
  • Array Cyberwar: What is it good for?
    In this week's episode, Cyberwar. What is Australia's place in the world of digital warfare? What are the implications for the NBN?
  • Array Is wholesale-only backhaul just a pipedream?
    The potential acquisition of Pipe Networks by SP Telemedia has raised the question about whether vertically integrated backhaul providers will mean higher wholesale prices for ISP customers.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured