Lawyers fight Aust moves to stall e-commerce patent

By Andrew Colley
01 August 2003 01:30 PM
Tags: tutaki, patent, colley, technologies, andrew, ecommerce, de, lawyer
The company trying to secure an e-commerce patent that could cost Australian businesses millions of dollars has instructed its lawyers to fight the latest move by an Australian tech executive to try to overturn its application.

Syntropy Systems' business development manager, Matthew Tutaki, said he had received notification from IP Australia that lawyers representing the company, D.E. Technologies, would fight his move to have the three-month cooling-off period -- required before a patent application is sealed in Australia -- extended.

Tutaki said a New Zealand-based law firm had argued that there was no valid reason to extend the cooling-off period and demanded that the patent assessment authority seal the patent.

He said it was very likely that he would have to personally provide millions of dollars in legal fees to in a bid to quash the patent in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT).

If approved, the patent would give D.E. Technologies the ability to demand royalties valued at millions of dollars per year from Australian companies that conduct international e-commerce transactions.

The patent, described as "predatory" by deputy chair of the Senate Standing Committee on Communications, Information Technology and the Arts, Senator John Tierney, was filed by D.E. Technologies in 32 countries. It was passed by New Zealand authorities, and lawyers representing the company have began demanding royalty and license fees from businesses there early this month.

Tutaki had pleaded with federal authorities to review the decision to recognise the patent in Australia and filed an eleventh-hour application for more time to challenge the patent.

Tutaki is praying that the federal government stops the patent before legal action is required but conceded yesterday that it was now "very probable" that the dispute would be taken to the AAT.

According to Tutaki an engaging a patent lawyer for the nine months that it could take to fight IP Australia's decision could cost AU$2 million to AU$3 million.

"If I hadn't have received so much support from people, and so many people hadn't stood up and said this is fundamentally wrong then possibly I would never have done it," he said.

Tutaki has received around 5,000 e-mails of support since placing himself at the head of the campaign to stop the patent, one percent of which have offered financial support to quash it. However he said he was "loath" to ask any of them for financial backing.

"It shouldn't be down to people that don't have any money to do this; the patent should never have got up in the first place," he said.

However Tutaki concedes that if the case goes to the tribunal he may have to accept third-party financial support.

Advertisement

Talkback 9 comments

    The government should be revie ...Anonymous -- 01/08/03

    The government should be reviewing the patent application process with the intention to introduce measures preventing the granting of patents which could have an adverse effect on the australian economy.
    How can we allow this overseas company to come here and be granted the right to funnel millions of dollars from our economy? This is one issue which urgently needs federal government intervention.

    The responsible Minister, Sena ...Keith Styles -- 01/08/03

    The responsible Minister, Senator Alston, as usual just sits back and does nothing! It's difficult to understand why with all his legal training he wastes his time haggling with the ABC over trivialities instead of defending the countries business commmunity and ultimately all our society, from what appears to be one of the worst cases of probable fraud by an overseas interest. If the government does not step in quickly, it will be all over bar the shouting and the cost will be huge. Will this be another case of a backslapping government doing nothing except brown nosing?

    The responsible Minister, Sena ...Keith Styles -- 01/08/03

    The responsible Minister, Senator Alston, as usual just sits back and does nothing! It's difficult to understand why with all his legal training he wastes his time haggling with the ABC over trivialities instead of defending the countries business commmunity and ultimately all our society, from what appears to be one of the worst cases of probable fraud by an overseas interest. If the government does not step in quickly, it will be all over bar the shouting and the cost will be huge. Will this be another case of a backslapping government doing nothing except brown nosing?

    This is yet another case of pa ...Anonymous -- 01/08/03

    This is yet another case of patents being used to earn money where none is deserved.

    Any time now, if not already, the patent system will be considered a pathetic joke and ignored for what it should stand for.

    I wholeheartedly agree with Ja ...Con Zymaris -- 02/08/03

    I wholeheartedly agree with Jason and the other commentors. Software patents and business process patents have been one the biggest industry problems outlined by the Free and Open Source communities for many years now.

    To read why:

    http://lpf.ai.mit.edu/Patents/patents.html

    "Patently Absurd". A ...Anonymous -- 02/08/03

    "Patently Absurd". A good article for anyone that is interested.

    http://www.around.com/patent.html

    I agree with the other posts, we cannot let a spiraling out of control american patent system restrict Australian Innovation.

    Patents Anonymous -- 18/01/06 (in reply to #120031586)

    its just another example of how american imperialist lawyers viciously attack the interests of other countries and why they in turn are being attacked .If ever there was an accursed 'profession' its has to be US patent lawyers . I notice DE Tech is just a bunch of 'patent lawyers' i.e not inventors just jackals!!.... Down with these rabid dogs of imperialism and the US patent system

    Patents Anonymous -- 18/01/06 (in reply to #120031586)

    its just another example of how american imperialist lawyers viciously attack the interests of other countries and why they in turn are being attacked .If ever there was an accursed 'profession' its has to be US patent lawyers . I notice DE Tech is just a bunch of 'patent lawyers' i.e not inventors just jackals!!.... Down with these rabid dogs of imperialism and the US patent system

    Agree with all the other posts ...Terry Fake -- 03/08/03

    Agree with all the other posts.
    Just another example of the Government sitting back and allowing the country's commercial functions to be dictated by foreign lawmakers, then waking up to the damage after the patent is allowed.
    Especially agree with the financial drain to foreign shore for absolutely no local effort.
    Colonialism by financial control.

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Suzanne Tindal IT: Govt's cost-cutting bitch
    The government needs to stop looking at IT as a necessary evil or the place to remove costs when the Treasurer comes calling.
  • Array Can complaints on mobile content be cut?
    On 1 July this year the new Mobile Premium Services Code was introduced. It sounds like it's had a good impact, but is it enough?
  • Array NZ farmers: Bleating about broadband
    As we know, farmers are such bleaters. They bleat as much as the four-legged woolly things in their paddocks. If it's not the weather, it's the strength of the dollar! Nothing is ever right. Likewise with rural broadband.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured