ICT skills foundering on poor data and disinterest

Lingering doubts about information and communications technology (ICT) careers, inadequate ICT teaching, an ineffective industry reporting structure and poor collaboration between public and private sectors have all been blamed for the poor state of Australia's ICT skills tracking in a report released yesterday.

The report, delivered to Minister for Communications, Information Technology and the Arts Helen Coonan by the ICT Skills Foresighting Working Group (SFWG), was quick to highlight the rapid growth of the ICT industry over the past two decades but found little to admire in the way the industry was being developed.

Despite the "vast amount of data" available about ICT skills across the industry, the group found that the data wasn't being shared or utilised in ways that would more effectively support the country's ICT industry. This criticism was levelled both at government organisations and the private sector, hindering the ability of labour market specialists to meaningfully assess the ICT skills market's current position and predict future demand.

The only shining light noted by the group was an effort by the IT Contract and Recruitment Association (ITCRA) which, in conjunction with Multimedia Victoria, has been funnelling data from 32 recruitment members into a database to track IT placements over time.

Coonan's response was to announce the formation of a National ICT Skills Tracking and Monitoring System that will build on the ITCRA model but expand the scope nationwide. To improve analysis, this data will be aligned with standard ANZSCO occupation classifications, and published regularly for all states and territories.

A related effort, the Skills Australia portal being established by the Department of Education, Science and Training and Department of Employment and Workplace Relations, will also track areas of skill shortage and future opportunity within the 356,600-strong ICT industry.

If lack of information about ICT positions is one problem, lack of interest emerged as another ongoing theme. "There is an urgent need to address the negative perception of ICT careers in the community," Coonan conceded, "as it is turning many young people away from considering a career in this dynamic sector. Building and maintaining a sustainable and world-class ICT workforce and ICT skills base is necessary to meet the current and future needs of the economy".

SFWG's primary recommendation was the formation of an industry leadership group whose mission is to improve information about ICT careers and foster participation amongst students. The group will have its work cut out for it: a recent Victorian government study, the report notes, found that 72 percent of 17 to 19 year olds didn't know much about the ICT courses offered at university; only 10 percent of respondents showed "strong interest" in an ICT career; six percent planned to do an ICT course at university; and 59 percent said the greatest disincentive to working in ICT was being stuck in front of a computer all day.

Such "outmoded" perceptions were noted as a major problem by the report, which also highlighted the Victorian survey's finding that school visits, work placements, and ICT company-sponsored competitions were all judged by students to be effective in spreading the word. The SFWG recommended funding of a National ICT Awareness Campaign that would dovetail into related efforts such as the new Career Advice Australia Web site.

Even as the SFWG and minister were in agreement that Australia's ICT industry needs better information about its future opportunities, the report didn't mince words in its assessment of the country's overall ICT labour force strategy.

"The combined impacts of the ageing workforce, changing generational patterns of work and the apparent failure of many employers to upgrade workplace skills," the group wrote, "could mean that Australia risks being unable to sustain key ICT-based economic capabilities, operations and services in the future".

Talkback 4 comments

    IT Sucks Anonymous -- 22/06/06 (in reply to #120136412)

    if i went to tafe and learned carpentry i woudl be learning a skill that i could carry through my entire life vs everything i learn in IT being superseded every couple of months (if not more frequently).

    recruiters have a long list of exact and unrealistic skills the potential candidates must match, makign gettign a job even harder.

    let's not kid ourselves, companies dont want to upgrade training for ict workers - its an expense for them.

    the number of nights i've squandered sorting through bugs and trying to learn product x because an employer wont train me is ludicrous, while my tradey mates finish their day and are busy shagging women at the local nightclub.

    IT is a dead end career. you cant polish a turd. get out while you can.

    You reap what you sew Anonymous -- 22/06/06 (in reply to #120136413)

    While I *kind* of agree with some of the sentiments you are putting forward, I do have to disagree overall.

    I have been a professional contractor in the industry for nearly 12 years and in that time I would say there has been little problem, a high return and not a great deal of "hard work" required (note: this is totally different to *smart* work... those who work hard are obviously doing it wrong).

    While it is true that you must constantly update your skills, you simply cannot replace good practices and I find those who have a good solid base of HOW they go about gaining knowledge can re-use this for their entire career. That we learn new technologies every day is a bonus... I would much prefer this than your typical carpenter who is doing exactly the same thing that was done 2000 years ago... bore the living sh*t out of me!!

    The problem I see with the industry rests squarely on the shoulders of those who consume ICT. Major corporations and companies who NEED our services in order to survive yet think they can pay the wages of a data entry operator in order to get them. When a labourer expects you to pay $50/hr for their services nobody blinks because they know the service must be done... but when a fully qualified, experienced and professional programmer charges the same amount managers run around pulling their hair out as if they were held up at gun point.

    You get what you pay for... and managers constantly hire "cowboys" simply becuase they are cheap and end up costing themselves even more than what it would have cost if they had skilled the job more appropriately in the first place.

    So if the industry sucks... its because of those who consume our skills undervaluing them to pinch a few pennies... What student in their right mind would want to be an ICT worker when the brickie next to them gets paid twice as much to sling bricks around?

    Work should be rewarded based on the benefit it has to those who consume it.... not by how far you can push a person into the ground by undercutting the professional market with cowboys.

    Agree.. but it's "sow" FYI Anonymous -- 27/06/06 (in reply to #120136420)

    ...unless you spent 12 years in the textile industry.

    :-)

    Depends how you go about it Andy Goss -- 24/06/06 (in reply to #120136413)

    Many employers prefer to keep their IT staff ignorant, there is less chance of them leaving. Years of experience of a vile home-grown system are of value to the employer, but worthless to the employee. If you want that kind of future you can have it, otherwise you will have to train, at your own expense, in something marketable and maybe even interesting. It will cost thousands of dollars and soak up all your "spare" time for months or years, but it will get you airborne.
    Unless you have a genuine interest in some aspect of IT, and will enjoy learning new things for the rest of your life, then go and be a tradesman. As there is a dire shortage of trade apprentices do not let me discourage you from that - most carpenters I have met get great satisfaction from their work, which is more than can be said for many IT workers who have fallen into the "big company" trap.
    Most of the interesting work is with small, specialised outfits where job security is uncertain, and workloads fluctuate wildly.
    Of course some people prefer to be unhappy and resentful, they can then blame someone else for the failures in their lives.
    In the end it is all down to you.

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Brad Howarth The key Topik is always money
    One of the big problems of the internet is that is practically impossible to keep up-to-date on preferred topics. You can limit your sources, but this can mean missing a lot of valuable data.
  • Array Google open-sources JavaScript tools
    Google announced overnight the release and open-sourcing of a trio of tools designed to help JavaScript developers.
  • Array Do we need the legislative blackmail?
    Virtually everyone in the telecommunications industry has their say in the Senate Standing Committee's public hearing into the pending legislation to split up Telstra, in this week's Twisted Wire podcast.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured