E-Commerce in Australia - A customer perspective

OPINION: Since its inception, e-commerce has promised much, but has it delivered? Depending on who you ask, online trading has been both a godsend to the retail sector and a nuisance that's more trouble than it's worth. One Sydneysider offers his real-life experiences of shopping online, along with his list of e-commerce winners and losers.

B2C e-commerce, it's such a great idea if you're a 20 something male like me that hates shopping centres. The idea of logging on from home, buying what you want and then going back to playing on the Playstation whilst the postie lugs your purchase to your house is great. "Have credit card, will shop", as my girlfriend always says.

The problem is that the reality doesn't match the promise. Out of the many B2C sites in Australia, there are so few that that deliver a basic level of service that I am looking for, which is not much. Here are a list of rules I think B2C companies really need to learn before they start to win the public over:

Deliver what you promise
If you have a Web site advertising next day delivery, then deliver it THE NEXT DAY. If you can only get it out in five days, then say that and don't exaggerate about it.

Accurately represent your products
If you are selling products on the Web, don't exaggerate the claims. If you do so, when I get the substandard item you have sold me, I wont visit your site again.

Actually stock the items you list on your site
Online wine retailers take particular note here, because so many times I have ordered products online, only to phone a week later when my order has not arrived, only to find you are out of stock and can't deliver it for five weeks.

Web sites that failed me so far include :-

Innovations
The worst online shopping experience I've had to date. Not only did the delivery eventually take 3 weeks, but the customer service staff were rude and unhelpful, blaming me for its fulfilment problem. The product has now stopped working after 4 months and I don't want to deal with this particular site again, even to get it replaced.

Dstore
Nice site and friendly staff. I ordered two radios which, according to the site, "normally ship in 24 hours". After a week of waiting, I called them to find out where the products were, only to be informed that they only had one in stock. Dstore said it would send the first radio out and refund my credit card with the money I had already paid for the second . It turned up after another week.

Wineplanet
Out of the 12 bottles I ordered, they only had two in stock. It did, however, help me choose some more. The point still is, why advertise them for sale if it din't have them in stock ?

Adultshop
Poor delivery but good customer service skills. Still shipped my order after 10 days instead of the "Next Day" as the Web site promised. It took three emails from me before they finally shipped it, the delay being due to a "Warehouse problem".

Promises kept

Sanity Music
A gold star should be awarded to this site, which provided a great service, delivered my CD in 48 hours without me having to call and chase it up. I now buy all of my CD's through this site.

It's not rocket science to make money in the retail marketplace, and there are plenty of customers keen to start shoping on the Internet. Many of the current online retail outlets, however, still seem determined to ruin the experience and drive customers away.

There are 1,000's of people like me who are online all day - no kids, high disposable income - who would use B2C business more if it worked. Why is this so hard for E-Tailers to understand ?

My name is Richard Talbot and I live in Sydney. I work in the CBD for a Recruitment Company and I spend all day online via a broadband Internet connection for my work (like most people I know). I work hard, often 12 hours or more a day in the office, and my spare time is in very short supply, hence I would prefer to shop online during the day and free up more time for fishing and spending time with my girlfriend.

Advertisement

Talkback 6 comments

    I agree totally with the persp ...Scott Leech -- 27/09/01

    I agree totally with the perspective, but things are changing. There is a web site that has come into effect about a year ago, this site has one of the best delivery systems around.

    They deliver once a week, which day depends on the postcode of the area. Here you can buy your general houshold goods and have them delivered to your door (some rural areas to a designated drop off point).

    The web site is www.a2k.com.au and is worth checking out. This is the future of E-Commerce in Australia and it WILL deliver as promised. They haven't failed me yet :-)

    Richard, Maybe you should try ...David Walsh -- 27/09/01

    Richard,
    Maybe you should try the other end of the market. Some of the smallest e-tailers are the best.
    <p><a href="http://www.kiewaview.com">www.kiewaview.com</a></p>
    <p>&nbsp;</p>
    Is about the smallest accommodation operator in Australia with one of the most comprehensive web sites. We only market across the internet. No Phone or Fax and have full e-commerce. Check it out.

    AdultShop.com welcomes feedbac ...AdultShop.com -- 27/09/01

    AdultShop.com welcomes feedback like this - thank you Richard for letting us know. AdultShop.com states that delivery is usually within three working days - orders are usually processed within 48 business hours, and delivery to most areas is on the next day (should this not be the case, our customer service team will send an email notifying the individual customer) Details regarding our delivery policy can be found at the URL below:

    http://shop.adultshop.com/helpdesk/shipping.html

    Unfortunately, in Richard's experience, this was not the case.

    AdultShop.com values customer service and individual customer experiences, and finding out stories like this (as well as the good ones!) allows us to recognise problems and rectify the situation.

    From the team at AdultShop.com, Richard we hope you do shop with us again so that we can provide you with a very positive shopping experience, and for all of our other customers and e-commerce users, we hope you will experience our service for yourselves!

    AdultShop.com was voted the number one e-commerce site in Australia by ZDNet, in 2001, with customer service being an important criterion. Feedback such as Richard's facilitates ongoing optimisation and improvement.

    We are known for saying "Moan, moan, moan. That's all we ever hear from our customers" but we were referring to moans of pleasure, not complaint! We do hope we provide pleasure the great majority of the time.

    Happy shopping everyone!

    The AdultShop.com team.

    I have ordered from major onli ...Deej -- 27/09/01

    I have ordered from major online retailer's within Australia on more than a few occasion's , and at all times I have been bitterly dissapointed.

    Harvey Norman was one of them; 3 week's after the order was placed online , at the website , the status page had "The vendor has received your submission and is considering your request".

    I did some considering of my own and cancelled the order. The product was the pc game Half-Life.

    Dick Smiths. NOTHING is ever in stock , check the site out , nothing is there , there is always a notice at the bottom of the page stating "currently unavailable and we will back order" or something just like it.

    Estore has copies of Windows XP in stock , kinda impressive considering they can't possibly have it yet.

    ISWH > International Software Warehouse. This company was a shocker. Received a catalogue in the mail and it advertised an external modem which I wanted , so I went to their website and ordered it......after giving them my credit card number and not seeing anything mentioning unavailability (also I had received the catalogue that day , so I assumed they had plenty) I ordered the modem.

    I was told an email would be sent to my email address , so I went to my inbox and read what I didn't want to see.......that we have no stock and we will be getting some in the next 6 days or so. A week passes , nothing.....another week , nothing.

    3 and a half week's and the incorrect modem later , I ring up to cancel the order and receive the good new's that "we don't have the modem's and we won't be getting the shipment for a while yet".

    WHY DIDN'T THEY JUST TELL ME THIS AT THE BEGINING!

    Oh and by the way , they debited my credit card and I didn't get the money back til like....2 month's later. P.S the company is also affiliated with City Software I believe.

    I agree with the author. I bu ...Anonymous -- 27/09/01

    I agree with the author. I buy a lot over the Internet because I hate going out shopping.

    Internet shopping allows me to use my spare time more productively.

    My experience with internet shopping is probably 50/50. I had several disappointments.

    On the other hand I now have about a dozend regular shopping sites which are very quick, reliable and deliver as promised.

    I also noticed that many sites seem to over promise and under delivery, this is a very common problem and I do not use these sites again after I had been disappointed.

    My company, Global Reviews, ha ...Adir Shiffman -- 28/09/01

    My company, Global Reviews, has purchased multiple times from every major e-tailer over a 12 month period. We make our findings publicly available at www.globalreviews.com.au so for those interested in e-commerce it may be worth checking out.

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Suzanne Tindal IT: Govt's cost-cutting bitch
    The government needs to stop looking at IT as a necessary evil or the place to remove costs when the Treasurer comes calling.
  • Array Can complaints on mobile content be cut?
    On 1 July this year the new Mobile Premium Services Code was introduced. It sounds like it's had a good impact, but is it enough?
  • Array NZ farmers: Bleating about broadband
    As we know, farmers are such bleaters. They bleat as much as the four-legged woolly things in their paddocks. If it's not the weather, it's the strength of the dollar! Nothing is ever right. Likewise with rural broadband.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured