Does Australia need digital music downloads?

Angus Kidman
17 November 2003 11:30 AM
Tags: australia, digital, music, kidman, angus, downloads, sold, single
Claims that the market for music singles is dying and will be replaced by downloads appear premature -- at least in Australia.

The U.S. music industry last week passed a major milestone when the best-selling paid download, Hey Ya by Outkast, sold more copies than the top-ranking commercial single, I Can Only Imagine by MercyMe.

According to Billboard, which publishes the official U.S. music charts, Outkast sold 8,000 downloads via a variety of services, while the MercyMe single sold 7,000 units.

Compared to those numbers, the Australian market looks positively blooming. Despite a much smaller population, Australia's current number one single, Kylie Minogue's Slow, sold 13,037 copies in its first week, according to music news site Undercover, which leaked the official Australian Recording Industry Association sales figures.

The Minogue track has achieved this success despite being made available as a paid download -- the first for a major chart act in Australia -- and also achieving widespread pirate distribution on networks such as Kazaa and WinMX. While digital download services such as Apple's iTunes have been successful in the U.S., none have yet launched in the local market. A number of players, including Telstra and Destra, plan to introduce services before the end of the year.

Advertisement

Talkback 7 comments

    I think if there were statistics showing the number of australians who had downloaded the new kylie single "slow" from p2p file trading services, this obviously ignorant reporter would have egg over his face.Anonymous -- 17/11/03

    I think if there were statistics showing the number of australians who had downloaded the new kylie single "slow" from p2p file trading services, this obviously ignorant reporter would have egg over his face.

    If downloading music from the net was to be the norm, then does one really think everyone will automatically move over to a broadband connection? Don't think so. It would be better to have both CD and Download to cover bothsides of the buying market! Anonymous -- 17/11/03

    If downloading music from the net was to be the norm, then does one really think everyone will automatically move over to a broadband connection? Don't think so. It would be better to have both CD and Download to cover bothsides of the buying market!

    I still use a dial-up and am happy to buy my cd's. I don't buy a lot of CD's as I don't have a lot of *disposable income*, and I don't like every band/singer to warrant buying more.

    The reason (IMO) why cd singles do so poorly in sales is to do with the fact that an artist (with Kylies' calibre) have so many good songs/hits on them, that I would rather pay more for the album than to buy 6-8 singles! Another example is 'The Eminem Show' made in 2002 but recently had a hit song on the charts! This would have been Eminems 6th hit or so from this album.

    If the record (CD) companies move over to a download only system, then I'll simply visit my friend and ask if he can burn it for me as I won't be able to pay for my purchase due to bandwidth constraints.

    In any case, I think the biggest mistake the music companies made in the 90's, and a decision which they ARE ALL REGRETTING now, is moving music onto the CD medium. Guess their cost cutting; aka: "let's make even more profits" idea didn't pay off for them. Maybe going back to vinyl will end this feud for once and for all.

    YES Australia does need digital music downloads. Looks at the success of Apples iTunes Music Store. 99cents US per song and you only download what you want, not what the record companies make you buy. I hardly buy music anymore mainly Anonymous -- 18/11/03

    YES Australia does need digital music downloads.

    Looks at the success of Apples iTunes Music Store. 99cents US per song and you only download what you want, not what the record companies make you buy.

    I hardly buy music anymore mainly because its too expensive to buy CD singles, and when you buy an album there is only 2 or 3 good songs on them making them a total waste of money.

    If Australia had Apples ITMS I would be more tempted to download music online because it would be the music I want to listen to at a better price and I wouldnt have the problems of storing bulky CD's all over the place. I could simply import the music into my computer, and my iPod and listen to it wherever I went, without the annoyance of carrying CD's everywhere.

    Who wouldnt want the ease and convenience of downloading their favourite music 24hours a day at a price (hopefully close to the 99c US that Apple ITMS charges) thats a fraction of the $7-10 you pay now for CD singles, and then if you really want, you can burn all your favourite songs (not all the crappy songs the record companies make you buy on a CD) on a disc to play in the car or at parties etc.

    IMO most people ilegally download music because its way too expensive to buy, if there were a digital music download service people would be happy to use it and be happy to part with their money. The iTunes Music Store has proved this, which is why every man and his dog are now copying the concept.

    In short, YES Australia does need a digital music download service !.

    $7-10 for a CD single????? Man.... the guy above must be getting ripped off by the music store! Shop around at BigW/Kmart - singles are about $4ea. I bought Kylie's Fever album at Kmart for $15 (2 cd special pack).Anonymous -- 18/11/03

    $7-10 for a CD single????? Man.... the guy above must be getting ripped off by the music store!

    Shop around at BigW/Kmart - singles are about $4ea. I bought Kylie's Fever album at Kmart for $15 (2 cd special pack).

    Yes - But... The music industry needs to start becoming more proactive. First - Let's look at music videos. Music video royalties pay four times as much as radio. When music videos became popular, the recording giants started to increaPeter Batten -- 20/11/03

    Yes - But...

    The music industry needs to start becoming more proactive.

    First - Let's look at music videos. Music video royalties pay four times as much as radio. When music videos became popular, the recording giants started to increase profits and found this was a more effective method to sell their products - YES, TV sells!!!

    With the likes of new interactive shows like "Australian Idol" which hook in young voters that become attached to these performers, which intern, go and buy their CD - fuels only success for the industry - in which they need to adopt a more innovative approach to marketing their products, rather then be re-active to innovative technologies that are forcing change they have not yet adopted.

    Record companies can not rely on sales of CD's alone - YES we need digital downloads at cheaper prices - but the record companies are scared of loosing money from poor margins, rather then adopting a more savy marketing approach to maintain profit margins which can be through the sale of merchandising and/or live performances.

    Absolutely! I'm sick of paying through the nose for CD singles. I'm sick of being forced into buying albums which I don't want for the sake of a couple of good tracks. I'm sick of not being able to find the music I want in the shops ie a narrow and limiteAnonymous -- 22/01/05

    Absolutely! I'm sick of paying through the nose for CD singles. I'm sick of being forced into buying albums which I don't want for the sake of a couple of good tracks. I'm sick of not being able to find the music I want in the shops ie a narrow and limited amount of stock offered. There are currently three great songs I want to buy from well known groups.........can I get them (without having to buy albums at ridiculous prices)....hell no!!!!!! When it comes to buying and downloading music, Australia seems to be a long way behind the rest of the world. All very sad and very frustrating!!

    Absolutely! I'm sick of paying through the nose for CD singles. I'm sick of being forced into buying albums which I don't want for the sake of a couple of good tracks. I'm sick of not being able to find the music I want in the shops ie a narrow and limiteAnonymous -- 22/01/05

    Absolutely! I'm sick of paying through the nose for CD singles. I'm sick of being forced into buying albums which I don't want for the sake of a couple of good tracks. I'm sick of not being able to find the music I want in the shops ie a narrow and limited amount of stock offered. There are currently three great songs I want to buy from well known groups.........can I get them (without having to buy albums at ridiculous prices)....hell no!!!!!! When it comes to buying and downloading music, Australia seems to be a long way behind the rest of the world. All very sad and very frustrating!!

Add your opinion


Latest Videos

Blogs

  • Chris Duckett PayPal launches Aussie developer program
    PayPal announced the opening of its certification program for Australian developers today, making Australia the first country outside of the US to offer certification.
  • Array Cash cow in a BigTinCan?
    Around one third of Australia's telcos have shut their doors over time, but that isn't stopping new ventures hoping to chip away at carriers' mobile call bonanza. By fighting carriers at the smartphone rather than the home phone, could the latest two contenders be onto something big?
  • Array A third of the way to a zettabyte
    This week on Twisted Wire we look at how internet usage is changing in Australia and around the world. How are we meeting this demand and how is the cost structure changing for the service provider?
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured