Dispute brews over immigration crackdown on IT workers

By Andrew Colley
27 November 2003 05:10 PM
Tags: imigration, 457, i457, visa, tmp, hudson, dimia, candle
The federal government is on a collision course with recruitment companies over recent tightening of rules for issuing the employer-sponsored 457 visas held by thousands of imported IT professionals.

The Department of Immigration, Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (DIMIA) has opted under new powers granted to it in October to enforce regulations disqualifying third parties from sponsoring overseas workers on behalf of employers.

DIMIA has reportedly advised the IT Contractors and Recruitment Association that its members must comply with the regulation -- which has been in place since 1997 -- within 90 days from 1 November 2003.

However, it appears that some IT recruitment companies have taken a position on the regulations which is at odds with DIMIA's official stance on the matter.

A spokeswoman for the department told ZDNet Australia   that DIMIA's interpretation of the regulation forbids recruitment companies from acting as employers in order to recruit labour offshore.

"If these people are being sponsored in any way they have to be sponsored by the employer, not by the recruitment companies," said the spokeswoman.

However, according to Candle Recruitment commercial manager, Jonathan Naiman, DIMIA is reinterpreting its regulations to stamp out activities of unscrupulous contract management firms and are not trying to affect sponsoring by recruitment companies.

"We have regular communications with [DIMIA] and they have said that for recruitment companies they understand that's the way labour works and that was not an issue. The only issue was when the recruitment company outsourced those functions to a management company, not the practice of sponsoring," said Naiman.

Global recruitment firm TMP Hudson has admitted that some of its contractors have been impacted by recent changes to 457 visa regulations but appears not to have reached a conclusion on how to comply with the regulations.

"We are currently working with our external immigration advisors and the contract management companies, with whom we have relationships, to ensure that we comply with the changed regulations," said a spokesperson for TMP.

Australian Computer Society (ACS) president Richard Hogg said DIMIA was simply enforcing existing rules with more vigour, and it has given the government its full support.

Moreover, the ACS believes that the concerns of ITCRA, which has asked to meet with DIMIA in December to discuss the economic impact of the changes, are unfounded.

"We don't accept that there has been a change, so no transition should be necessary unless companies have been operating outside the rules," said Hogg in a statement.

"We are fully supportive of any moves by DIMIA to more closely monitor 457 visas and rigorously apply the rules and don't believe anyone should be allowed to flout them, particularly since doing so disadvantages Australia's own ICT professionals".

Advertisement

Talkback 5 comments

    When will countries stop this ...A.C. -- 28/11/03

    When will countries stop this ridiculous tendancy to try to keep everyone else out? You'd think Australia would have more sense, considering the Australian economy was built not on the sheeps back, but on the back of immigrants. Throughout the history of Australia it has been the new immigrants which have driven our economy.

    And now the government are trying to keep them out. Well done.

    Australia should focus on prov ...neo -- 28/11/03

    Australia should focus on providing jobs for it's current citizens, and where current citizens don't have a specific skill they should be "trained" especially in IT - now there's a concept recruitment agents and manager's with their unrealistic expectations won't like to hear.

    Cleanup our backyard first (there are many skilled unemployed IT professionals here).

    That's just common sense.

    AC, this is about temporary wo ...Anonymous -- 28/11/03

    AC, this is about temporary workers being imported outside immigration arrangements by greedy recruiters. This harms work opportunities for immigrants and for local workers.

    Guys, The government and the i ...Anonymous -- 01/12/03

    Guys,
    The government and the industry should be looking at ways to CREATE more jobs not taking away existing jobs.

    We talk about training 'newbies' in the industry, most of these foreign workers are not sweat shop workers, rather they are highly skilled, experienced and expensive. Many employers i know swear by them because, they dont have the time to train fresh grads into high pressure jobs in a short time.

    You people expect to get into a high paying jobs by eliminating good experienced workers and replacing them with inexperienced dummies.

    The only thing you are doing is driving down the IT industry. I find it funny when people say we have skilled people in this country, they are either in UK, or somewhere else. Just coming out of IT or having worked in IT many years ago during the boom doesnt make you qualified. Its the skills and experience employers are after. This is one thing the government or the industry is unable to provide.

    I am sorry you guys aren't able to drive your flash cars or spend as much time at the pub anymore but please do consider these hard working, extremely experienced people who have been holding up the IT industry.

    I dont see any threats with ha ...Anonymous -- 07/03/04

    I dont see any threats with having migrants being recruited for IT jobs in Australia, considering there many of our own IT professionals who seek employment overseas. The lose and gain are balanced out.

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Phil Dobbie Is wholesale-only backhaul just a pipedream?
    The potential acquisition of Pipe Networks by SP Telemedia has raised the question about whether vertically integrated backhaul providers will mean higher wholesale prices for ISP customers.
  • Array Get extensions going in Firefox, redux
    Previously on Null Pointer we looked at getting extensions working in Firefox betas, and that was great until the fine folks at Firefox changed their minds.
  • Array How reliable is IP telephony?
    Have you ever heard a weird kind of hissing, crackling or popping noise when calling someone on an IP telephony line? How rare is the phenomenon these days?
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured