Alston slams the "baying dogs" of broadband

The Federal Minister for Communications and Information Technology used his key note address at the opening of ATUG's 2002 conference to describe those concerned that Australia is falling behind in broadband take up as -baying dogs".

-We are in line with most OECD countries in placing broadband rollout at the forefront of out communications policy," Alston said, dismissing claims the provision of broadband in Australia was not inline with other OECD countries.

N+I 2002 Special Coverage To support his statements, Alston choose to focus on the extent to which Australian's have access to broadband services, rather than the number of people accessing the services.

-The key measure is the availability of the service rather than adoption rates," Alston said, drawing the conclusion that the principal reason for slow take up was a lack of compelling content. He also expressed concern that any pricing controls placed on the industry, would inhibit investment.

In saying that broadband take up in the residential market would be predominantly entertainment-driven, he discounted any idea that the Federal Government may play a role in encouraging domestic use of broadband.

-It would be premature to assume that this push should be government supported," Alston said. However, he went on to underline the importance of broadcasting technologies in the provision of broadband connectivity describing the pay TV sector as a key component of the broadband sector.

-Our supply side approach, designed to promote competition and new market models, has been successful," Alston said. -Australia is well placed to take up broadband, given the infrastructure already in place and our propensity to take up new technologies."

Alston failed to indicate when the Broadband Advisory Group announced at the World Congress on IT last week would conveine, nor give any further indication who might take part, although he did recap on a litany of government spending aimed at developing broadband offerings and applications.

-Consumers are waiting for compelling content to give them the incentive to switch to broadband," Alston said.

Advertisement

Talkback 17 comments

    Yes we need more content and a ...Anonymous -- 05/03/02

    Yes we need more content and apps to take advantage of broadband.

    We need streaming media(both audio and video),
    Ability to share and transfer files,
    Abilty to communicate and collaborate with one another,
    Online gaming,
    Browsing,
    Email,
    etc...

    Wait a sec .... these are here now!!!!

    Hmmm, why isn't there more take up?????

    Is it infrastructure, nope, that can't be it. Everyone has access to BB.

    Hmmm, what else could it be???

    Reliability??? Price????

    Naaa, that can't be it. Could it????

    We need a new C&IT Federal ...Anonymous -- 05/03/02

    We need a new C&IT Federal Minister.
    Alston is our problem. He is living in the dark ages.

    The bloody luddite strikes aga ...Anonymous -- 05/03/02

    The bloody luddite strikes again!!!

    The luditte comments of the ci ...Anonymous -- 05/03/02

    The luditte comments of the city dwelling **** from Sydney is typical of the `Baying Hounds'.

    Anon ... is right the current content for broadband is crap ...

    In our regional area we had broadband services for about two years and the company went broke even though it promoted its services really heavily - why? - because the content was crap and the service was too expensive!!!!!!!!

    I'm a web developer and service around 200 sites across Australia from banks to B&Bs and have had only major businesses take up any sort of broadband access and mainly because of their VPN needs.

    When I investigated the pros and cons of the access price and volume charges I found no financial or other business benefits other than that junior propellor heads could play Doom quicker !!!!!!

    This I really needed in my office !!!

    I almost puked when I read thi ...Anonymous -- 05/03/02

    I almost puked when I read this. It's not availability. Ha! Just as I was going to sign up for ADSL (as it *was* available to my address) the men in white vans came and did something in the pit in our street. Now I'm lucky to get to get a 33.6kbps connection. Try complaining to them - the response is always the same: "no, you can't get ADSL at that address", and "sorry, we only guarantee internet connections to 24kbps".

    We need a new Communications m ...Anonymous -- 05/03/02

    We need a new Communications minister. Rather than blaming "lack of compelling ..." for a low uptake by consumers of broadband, he should look to Telstra's apparent inability to make ADSL (the clayton's broadband) work reliably and the higher consumer cost of (broadband) ADSL access imposed by Telstra (who are still trying to ensure their dominance in the marketplace). He needs to make Telstra focus on provision of domestic services with reasonable pricing and support rather than their love affair with "being entreprenuers" (and then raising tariffs to recoup their losses).
    If the Federal Government want to talk about "lack of compelling content" then perhaps they should look at stimulating the IT industry here - particularly the small business IT segment.
    We've had nothing except regressive, time consuming tax implementations and backflips, plus a prolonged "anticontractor" program. If the gov. stopped wasting time trying to defend the indefensible (immigrants, children in the sea, the GG, the discrimation against contractors, a giant tax stuffup, stopped tolerating telstra's lack of performance, need I go on) AND got some well qualified ministers then perhaps we'd be able to devote more to building the broadband market and stimulating the economy to boot.
    This is not a political statement - rather it is an expression of total frustration with incomptetence and lack of accountability by people who should be both competent and accountable (and who are neither but still get paid for it).

    I'm sick of these geriatric po ...Anonymous -- 05/03/02

    I'm sick of these geriatric politicians who claim to represent the people of Australia, having no vision or understanding of the technology available to us now. While other countries push on into the future, Australia as usual is kept behind by these politicians who simply do not plan for Australia's future... We could be a leader in the development of technology, yet our government insists on supporting industries which have little to no growth prospects. Wake up Australia, Alston is just too old to be making any decisions for us when it comes to technology matters. We need someone who is passionate about technology, not an old man who probably has trouble using an ATM.

    Cost of access is a driving fa ...Anonymous -- 05/03/02

    Cost of access is a driving factor for people not takingup the service. At present, it costs too damn much.
    We also need a Federal Minister who understands technology, rather than someone who can read a prepared speech.

    It's as easy as ABC. Alston's ...Anonymous -- 05/03/02

    It's as easy as ABC. Alston's Bloody Clueless.

    Internet!? - who needs it?? Ce ...Anonymous -- 05/03/02

    Internet!? - who needs it??
    Certainly not the knowledege nation!!
    Alston knows all!!
    Luddites unite!!

    Alston the idiot says:“The key ...Keith Styles -- 05/03/02

    Alston the idiot says:“The key measure is the availability of the service rather than adoption rates"

    We don't have either! T(H)elstra's ADSL has been a disaster for over 12 months. To add insult to injury, it is NOW horribly expensive. The Mad Hatters (Canberra) Tea Party rolls on producing nothing of real value for the Australain economy.

    Oh and by the way to Anonymous of Adelaide.
    T(H)elstra doesn't guarantee the copper network above 2.4 thats 2400bits/second, not 24Kbps. Who would want to use it for Internet access at 2.4kbps. So much for availabilty!

    I think Alston's comments are ...Eruch Bazanyian -- 05/03/02

    I think Alston's comments are bang on the mark. We really don't need "broadband" in Australia. It's a silly notion that will be soon forgotten once the novelty has worn off.

    What is needed is more investment in heavy industries, manufacturing and subsidies to the farming community. These form the pillars of production, not some silly packet-passing scheme over phone lines.

    I, for one, will vote for Alston as the first President of the People's Republic of Antipodea!

    Where does he think he is? We' ...John Fenech -- 05/03/02

    Where does he think he is?

    We're not some 3rd world tinpot country, we've paid for the rollout (and how), now all we want is the pricing structure to become more realistic and not only the top 10% of money earners being they only ones to afford having broadband access in this country.

    Why would you provide content ...Anonymous -- 05/03/02

    Why would you provide content that requires the use of broadband when very few can afford broadband?.

    The content would have to be almost critical to existance before most people would sign up at current prices!

    Incredible. How naive people a ...Anonymous -- 06/03/02

    Incredible. How naive people are nowadays. You don't need broadband *now* but you sure as hell will need it in the future. I work in a company that is hooked to the net sharing 256kbit amongst 60 or so people. Soon everything will be done with a Web interface so people who go on site can still access the base station databases and Office Management System. How can one expect to efficiently implement remote testing on 56k modem?

    That was just an industry example. As a home net user, I now have access to just about anything... banking or buying or viewing information about anything I want. Farmers may not care about time but I sure as hell do. Time is money and I don't want to have to wait minutes for pages to load each time I want to view something.

    If you can't accept that the net will be a part of life in the future (as it already is for some), then stay in your little hidy-hole in whoop-whoop. Ironic that you post on an internet news site.

    Sen Alston obviously do not fa ...Anonymous -- 06/03/02

    Sen Alston obviously do not factor cost and ridiculous capping of accounts in their accessibility calculations.

    For me the biggest advantage in Broadband is the always connected idea. With directories such as White and Yellow Pages, WhereIs, Public Transport timetables, Movie Times, etc, etc, etc being on line the home PC is becoming the link to the world. More and more services are available on line each day. Think of the cost saving in not having to print phone books each year.

    This seems to me to be a short-sighted view by our elected in Canberra.

    How about all the people that ...Anonymous -- 06/03/02

    How about all the people that live in home units???? Even if the cable goes right by the door - neither Optus or Telstra will connect you.
    Given the number of people (especially in Sydney) that do like in this type of home - it is CRAZY that this is the current situation. Do something about that - and straight away you will give access to a LOT more people. I would think this is a prime target - upwardly mobile, busy, high earners, usually no kids, live in units. The ones that will pay a premioum for the service because it enhances both personal and business lives.

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Suzanne Tindal Sick of broken tender sites
    Some of the state governments desperately need to invest in more user-friendly tender sites so that looking for information on government tenders doesn't have to be a game of blind man's bluff.
  • Array Cyberwar: What is it good for?
    In this week's episode, Cyberwar. What is Australia's place in the world of digital warfare? What are the implications for the NBN?
  • Array Is wholesale-only backhaul just a pipedream?
    The potential acquisition of Pipe Networks by SP Telemedia has raised the question about whether vertically integrated backhaul providers will mean higher wholesale prices for ISP customers.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured