E-banking Special: Summary Table
By Performance Technologies Group, 0
February 05, 2001
URL: http://www.zdnet.com.au/news/business/soa/E-banking-Special-Summary-Table/0,139023166,120150799,00.htm
ZDNet compares eight Australian e-banking sites in terms of current features, usability, and future developments. Take a look at which site tops the polls in this comprehensive summary.
|
Feature
|
Technology
|
Compatibility
|
Minimum specification
|
Balances
|
Transfers between accounts
|
NAB
|
Downloaded application
|
Intel PCs only
|
Pentium, IE or Netscape 4.01 or higher, win
95, 98, NT SP 3, 32MB Ram
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
|
CBA
|
Browser based
|
PC and Mac
|
Win 95, 98, NT, 2000, Mac OS 8.6, IE 4.02+,
IE 5+ (Mac), Netscape 4.72+, Netscape 4.6+ (Mac)
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
|
ANZ
|
Browser based
|
PC and Mac
|
Win 95, 98, NT, IE 4.72, Netscape 4.07
Mac OS (Any), IE 4.5, Netscape 4.07
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
|
Westpac
|
Browser based
|
PC and Mac
|
Win 3.1, 95, 98, NT Netscape 4.73 and IE 4+,
IE 4.5+ only on Mac, Netscape 4.73 on Linux
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
|
StGeorge
|
Browser based Java Application, but the application
can be downloaded for increased speed
|
PC and Mac
|
Win 95, 98, NT IE 4+, and Netscape 4.06+,
and Netscape 4.06+ on Mac only.
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
|
Bendigo Bank
|
Browser based
|
PC and Mac
|
IE 4+ and Netscape 4+
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
|
CitiBank
|
Browser based
|
PC
|
Pentium with 95, 98, and NT. IE 4.01+ and
Netscape 4.06+
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
|
Suncorp Metway
|
Browser based
|
PC
|
Win 3.0, 95, 98, NT, IE and Netscape 4.0+
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Summary table cont.
|
Feature
|
Transfers to other bank's accounts
|
Multiple / Batched Payments
|
BPay
|
Scheduled payments
|
Payroll file upload
|
|
NAB
|
Maximum of $5,000
|
|
Yes
|
Yes, up to 18 months in advance
|
No
|
|
CBA
|
No (Coming)
|
|
Yes
|
No (Coming)
|
No
|
|
ANZ
|
Yes, current maximum of $5,000, increasing
to $50,000 in near future
|
Yes, but cannot save the list for repeat use
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
No
|
|
Westpac
|
Yes, standard is $1,000 per day, or special
request for $5,000. Increasing to $25,000 in near future.
|
No (Coming)
|
Yes
|
No (Coming)
|
No (Coming)
|
|
StGeorge
|
Yes, up to $25,000. Must nominate the accounts
in advance using paper based request.
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
No (Coming)
|
|
Bendigo Bank
|
Yes, between $1,000 and $5,000
|
No
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
No
|
|
CitiBank
|
Yes, and international accounts
|
No
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
No
|
|
Suncorp Metway
|
Yes
|
No (Coming)
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
No
|
Summary table cont.
|
Feature
|
Accounting package integration
|
Statements
|
Access to others
|
Multiple Signature account support
|
Security Level
|
|
NAB
|
Downloads to MS Money, Quicken, and CSV format
|
Last 100 days of transactions
|
Customisable access for others, e.g. your
accountant
|
No
|
168 bit through the proprietary interface
Digital certificate for extra security.
Use at different PCs difficult.
|
|
CBA
|
Download to MS Money, Quicken (US and Australian)
and CSV
|
Last 150 transactions
|
No
|
No
|
128 bit
|
|
ANZ
|
Downloads to MS Money and Quicken
|
Up to 120 days of transactions
|
No
|
No
|
128 bit
|
|
Westpac
|
Downloads to MYOB v9 for Mac and PC, Quicken
v6 and 7, Excel, MS Money 98, 99/2000, and OFX
|
Last 100 days transactions, but statements
available for last 12 months
|
No
|
No (Coming)
|
128 bit
|
|
StGeorge
|
Downloads to CSV and QIF
|
Yes
|
No (Coming)
|
No (Coming)
|
128 bit
|
|
Bendigo Bank
|
No (Coming)
|
Yes, a minimum of 11 months' history
|
No
|
No (Coming)
|
128 bit
|
|
CitiBank
|
Downloads to MS Money, Quicken, OFX and CSV
|
Last 100 days
|
No
|
No
|
128 bit
|
|
Suncorp Metway
|
Sownloads to MS Money, Quicken, ASCII
|
Last 25 transactions (being updated to last
12 months)
|
No
|
No (Coming)
|
128 bit
|
Summary table cont.
|
Feature
|
Other
|
Usability
|
Ease of getting started
|
Overall Rating
|
|
NAB
|
Can open term deposits online
|
Average, took some time to get used
|
The download process is not foolproof, and
has to be done exactly right. Getting access is a laborious process.
|
3 / 5
|
|
CBA
|
Access to ComSec for share trading, small
business section on the website
|
Good, simple and straightforward interface
|
Easy, but can only access the service after
8am the next day.
|
3.75 / 5
|
|
ANZ
|
Access to E*Trade for share trading, web development
tools, and a strong SME focus
|
Excellent, clear and simple, with a good look
and feel
|
No significant problems, but could be simpler
and quicker
|
4 / 5
|
|
Westpac
|
Small business section on the website, WAP
services
|
Good, fairly simple and clear. But reduced
feature set makes it simple.
|
Access process is more complicated that it
needs to be.
|
3.5 / 5
|
|
StGeorge
|
SME section on the website, but not as well
integrated as others. Access to share trading through Quicktrade.
Ecash for internet transactions.
Endorsement of Business in a Box for SMEs
to develop their own Internet site.
|
Below average. The Java download did not take
full advantage of the flexibility of a download.
|
Ok, but could be simpler.
|
3.25 / 5
|
|
Bendigo Bank
|
Share trading is coming soon.
Strong rural focus.
|
Average. The systems was quite slow, and the
interface needs simplification and increased efficiency
|
Ok, but could be simplified
|
3 / 5
|
|
CitiBank
|
|
Low. A lot of inefficient steps and process
to get things done. Bugs apparent when using Netscape
|
The best of all - just enter your card number
and ATM PIN. You don't have to register or do anything special.
|
2 / 5
|
ZDNet's e-banking special report compares the online offerings of Australia'
s leading banks.
Copyright © 2009 CBS Interactive, a CBS Company. All Rights Reserved.
ZDNET is a registered service mark of CBS Interactive. ZDNET Logo is a service mark of CBS Interactive.
|