Mobile to go Wi-Fi within a year: Cisco

Technologists at telecommunications hardware provider Cisco have predicted that within the next few months mobile carriers will begin to use offloading to seamlessly load-balance data from cellular networks on to faster, lower-latency Wi-Fi networks.

At a media briefing in North Sydney last week, Cisco Systems Australia chief technology officer Kevin Bloch said that in the next 12 months, he expected that carriers like Telstra would begin to make use of Wi-Fi to help balance the load from their cellular networks.

Bloch and Cisco vice president of global technology policy, Dr Robert Pepper, said that it was entirely possible. He said they had already seen examples of the technology in work in the US, where a user could walk into a Starbucks with Wi-Fi access and have their phone automatically and seamlessly take advantage of the lower latency and faster connection of the hotspot, with the carrier charged for the usage.

The process, which the pair called offloading, would use the next generation of wireless hotspot infrastructure that would allow the user to be tracked and connected by identifying their SIM card. This would be used to tie the wireless device to the handset and make it possible to hand off the data connection and allow mobile carriers to bill for the added capability if it required.

According to Pepper, the advantage of using a hotspot would be that in small areas such as coffee shops, there would be the expectation that the number of users would be relatively low, reducing contention. However, both he and Bloch stressed that the back-end infrastructure needed to both support the hand-off process and be connected to a high-capacity backbone, such as fibre.

Businesses struggling with 3G blackspots, but who had existing Wi-Fi investments would be quick to form relationships with mobile carriers, Bloch said, explaining that business users would appreciate the additional bandwidth an immediate Wi-Fi offload would give them.

"Let's say I want to do a print from my iPad. If I do that over 3G on my mobile ... you have a bandwidth constraint. I'm shoving it all the way back to the exchange and coming back to print, whereas with Wi-Fi, I go straight to the printer," Bloch said.

One thing offloading would help solve, said Pepper, with the aid of fibre roll-outs, was latency. He said that in the future, latency would become more important in applications such as collaborative cloud computing. In these cases, he said latency of less than 50ms — a figure that he said most countries' networks had trouble achieving — would become the bare minimum standard to make these applications usable.

He further pointed to the example of future traffic systems where a highway's early warning system might automatically communicate with vehicles in the event of an unexpected incident and require sub-millisecond response times.

As to when offloading would be delivered, Bloch said carriers that were further behind than others, such as Vodafone, would take longer to develop such networks and could not simply use Wi-Fi as a shortcut to improve their performance.

"What [Vodafone have] got to do, in my opinion, and what they're doing is making sure they're getting back up to speed with their existing business. When they get their head above that ... then they will probably have to think about other things like Wi-Fi," he said.

"They, of the three, have got their work cut out for them. It's not a shortcut because at the end of the day, [phones] talk to the network via 3G licensed spectrum."

Talkback

Didn't Telstra recently closed down its WiFi network? Surely they wouldn't have done that if they were planning to use WiFi for mobile broadband offload?

DanW1DanW1 February 28th, 2012
Report offensive content Reply (+1) (0)

Yes, Telstra dumped the silly concept of having wi-fi hotspots everywhere because there 3G and 4G network speeds were often faster than the hotspots which in most cases were limited to ADSL backhaul speeds.
These silly Cisco execs should wake up and understand the Australian telco market a little better. We don't copy what the stupid yanks do. Mobile carriers in the USA have stupidly congested and bandwidth limited networks that they have horrible wireless data speeds compared to here in Australia and as a result they have no choice but to offload on to Wi-fi networks.
The prediction in this article is one of the most silly predictions I've heard come out of Cisco. Until our last mile fixed internet access networks improve considerably (which only the NBN will resolve over time) there isn't a chance in hell that mobile carriers will be prepared to leach off slow ADSL connected wi-fi terminals for their customers. It's a crazy unviable solution. These Cisco execs should go back to ripping off customers with over-priced hardware and support contracts filled with bugs and leave our mobile comms market to do what it does best in rolling out more 3G and 4G sites. The last thing we need is for Australia to copy the USA mobile comms market which is a complete joke. Well done yanks on going your own way on developing your own myopic standards. How's that going for ya?

davmeldavmel February 28th, 2012
Report offensive content Reply (+1) (0)

You seem to have a strong opinion about this and that is good. However your assumptions don’t seem to be on target with the rest of the world. The US isn’t the only place trying to go Wi-Fi for data off load.
http://techcrunch.com/2011/11/02/beijing-set-to-roll-out-massive-free-public-wifi-network-this-month-but-theres-a-catch/
Maybe us “Yanks” (BTW: a term that implies a small part of the US not everyone) just have more users trying to get on the cell networks? Maybe only a few people in Australian have smart phones? The problem with cell phones is that they are made for range. This means a tower has to cover a large area and with it a large number of people. Since wireless is a shared medium this is a bad thing. Towers get over loaded with people trying stream videos, downloading apps and upload videos/pictures. Remember only one person can transmit at a time. Towers quickly run out of “air time”. Since the cell towers go so far you can’t reuse the channels to get the user density under controller.
That is why WiFi is coming on strong. The super small coverage cells allow you can reuse channels without interfering between them. If try to compare WiFi in a high client density areas, such as a city, it will blow cell towers out of the water. Being able to reuse channels is where the advantage comes in.

Your comment about slow ADSL connections isn’t a problem with the WiFi offload strategy, it is a problem with the infrastructure. Maybe Australia isn’t really for WiFi offload because the backbone isn’t there? One day you will have to get there. There is no reason to get mad at us “stupid yanks” because we got there before you. You should be happy you can learn from us as we pave the way for you.

WiFivomFranManWiFivomFranMan February 29th, 2012
Report offensive content Reply (+2) (0)

I think you need to consider the cross subsidy between voice, data and SMS and the effect of contention on speed in wireless networks. Within that context it makes eminent sense to offload certainly 3G and even LTE which Telstra suggests in worst case could run at less than 10% of the best case ADSL2+ speeds.

It additionally makes sense to offload voice traffic when the available WiFi network offers a higher QoS than is available over the LTE or 3G network.

From the carrier's perspective, allowing offloading directs traffic into cheaper (per megabit) access networks allowing them to defer CapEx and allowing for a more efficient allocation of network resources. Since the cost of enabling offloading is small in comparison to the cost of adding more mobile network capacity then its business case could well be justified.

apaddonapaddon February 29th, 2012
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

What are these guys smoking? Yeah my smartphone will automatically "off-load" onto a wifi network, but the carrier has no idea that it has done that. They can dream that they'd like to back-bill the carrier... good luck with that. (Notice how well the femtocell is working out, where they want me to pay twice, to my ISP _and_ my cell carrier, to carry my data?)

ptwithyptwithy March 1st, 2012
Report offensive content Reply (+2) (0)

Using existing technology, you're correct, but Cisco in this case is talking about the next generation of hotspots. How carriers bill isn't Cisco's concern -- they're just the equipment vendor after all -- but I would think that this addresses the current problems of double billing -if- it takes off.

-Michael

MukimuMukimu March 2nd, 2012
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

This idea isn't something for the future, it's happening now. Seoul South Korea are having Motorola deploy an extensive Wifi network, mainly for the purpose of 3G offload. How they are handling the "back-charging" of the telcos I have no idea.

brdanielbrdaniel March 3rd, 2012
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)
Add your opinion

In order to post a comment, you need to be registered. (Sign In or register below)

Post your comment

Terms of Service - As a ZDNet registrant, and by using this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understand our Privacy Policy.

ZDNet Australia Live

"take up of the highest plan was again higher in April, making up 50 per cent of all services activated in April"

5 minutes ago by Abel Adamski on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

What has not been considered which may well be the case, is the key attribute of the FTTP. Upload capability. 82% chose an upload capacit...

10 minutes ago by Abel Adamski on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

"@ECCOUNCIL: Cybercrime golden age over in two years? http://t.co/PiR0zeF1 #infosec #hack #cybersecurity"

Cool: NZ will host part of Square Km Array http://t.co/a2mz3DC5. Sad: @smh couldn't bring themselves to acknowledge it http://t.co/l90oLuYp

Build your own smartphone stand http://t.co/I0avWsRO

SKA bid ends in three-way tie: The bid to host the world's largest radio telescope, the Square Kilometre Array (... http://t.co/vA11Otks

SKA bid ends in three-way tie: The bid to host the world's largest radio telescope, the Square Kilometre Array (... http://t.co/FqSe1Uju

SKA bid ends in three-way tie AU/NZ/ZA http://t.co/aGw6dndH < interesting outcome

RT @MADinMelbourne: roxon "will enable more families to access credit" @MLolderandwiser: Privacy Act amendments http://t.co/Mv4c7PC2 via @zdnetaustralia

Is #PR dying at the hands of #SocialMedia? Check out how #UnitedAirlines suffered a Social PR hiccup in 2008 http://t.co/OVpYX8Uv

The interface is nowhere near as clean and user friendly as the Rdio streaming service apps. It doesn't compete with Rdio which has very ...

2 hours ago by Jeff12345 on Spotify finally goes live in Australia

RT @ECCOUNCIL: Cybercrime golden age over in two years? http://t.co/0rCoszCl #infosec #hack #cybersecurity

by http://t.co/vmlLt4bh: SKA bid ends in three-way tie: The bid to host the world's largest radio telescope, the ... http://t.co/ySDRbo3l

It's official. The SKA bid has ended in a three-way tie between Australia, South Africa and New Zealand: http://t.co/Wn1niauX ^LH

Biometric bugs too dangerous for public?
http://t.co/48XQpWiY

Aussies getting ripped off by retail: Choice http://t.co/6ZQ0wuCJ via @zdnetaustralia

Thats really interesting to find this post especially in this period of my life I'm Italian, I'm owner of a website that ships worldwide...

2 hours ago by salbini on Aussies getting ripped off by retail: Choice

Android's biggest security flaws - ZDNET - ZDNet Australia http://t.co/4j4R1x6Q

RT @Techmeme: RIP webOS: Again and for good this time (@jkendrick / ZDNet) http://t.co/RhADp6WL http://t.co/fFYGIy5R

Cybercrime golden age over in two years? http://t.co/LyqqjWYU #Cybercrime #Gescrise #Riskmanagement (via @ECCOUNCIL)

RT: ECCOUNCIL: Cybercrime golden age over in two years? http://t.co/X0In9ijs #infosec #hack #cybersecurity

Cybercrime golden age over in two years? http://t.co/VJnt6nEo #infosec #hack #cybersecurity

NBN users opt for 100Mbps - http://t.co/C2Vs7d3t

Yes, if only he had access to FTTP instead of wishing for wireless or space optics, perhaps the comedy site would still be up and running...

3 hours ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

I could not resist :-)

I remember that website well, you must too, it was full of so many comedy pieces.

3 hours ago by Hubert Cumberdale on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Bazaarvoice acquires rival PowerReviews; adds SMBs to CRM portfolio: By Andrew Nusca | May 25, 2012, 4:42am PDT ... http://t.co/WngvcsxL

MikeSkoey, what a naive collection of words. How do you know what context Paul has been working in. How do you know he implemented whats ...

4 hours ago by AnonymousCIO on 30 servers to 7: BUPA redoes virtualisation

Post 'social' improved speed to information and context http://t.co/7u9odG7N

HC, don't be so mean to Todd...

He is actually one who may not be just politically opposed ;-)

4 hours ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

No, Quigley is, as CEO's of all companies are, quite simply motivated for his company to be a professional and successful company, as it ...

4 hours ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Forced lol. btw I tried to load your website www.nonbn.org but all I got was a "website unavailable" I really wanted to donate some mone...

4 hours ago by Hubert Cumberdale on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

http://t.co/aDIOqQ4c http://t.co/NeUOcLt5

What has the debt level got to do with what plan people chose? I'd point out that the debt wont be $50 billion but i'd be wasting my bre...

4 hours ago by mstat_z on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Quigley is entirely politically motivated, this is headline grabbing and nothing more. The statistic should read - "of those who took up ...

5 hours ago by merarischroeder on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

RT @zdnetaustralia: NSW outs datacentre deal details: http://t.co/A1Cj4Eot ^LH

"the artificial speed tiers will mean that on average speeds the country will be left well behind others and social inequality will incre...

5 hours ago by Hubert Cumberdale on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

The most insulting aspect of the ads is CommBank's expectation that we would accept a bank account with fees unless you deposit $2000/mth...

5 hours ago by gikku on Triple J's Spotify conundrum

NBN users opt for 100Mbps - Communications - News http://t.co/3A84AASP

That's right. Quigley DOES know best. So when Quigley presents a plan to the shareholders (us) and says "this is our worst case scenario...

5 hours ago by Hubert Cumberdale on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

"NBNCo predict 13% of premises passed by fibre will opt for wireless because it is cheaper." Which leaves 87% well above the 70% estimate...

5 hours ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

HC the critics said the NBN wouldn't make a cent (yes, yes here comes the, it's still in debt arguments - we know what you meant and so d...

6 hours ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Look what you did Gwyn...LOL. Yes, but as you have been told umpteen times Mathew (whenever you sprout the same old repetitive lines abo...

6 hours ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

It's great that in one area NBNCo are beating the prediction on speed tiers in the Corporate Plan (page 118). Unfortunately it is the onl...

6 hours ago by mathew42 on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

10 cool iPad apps you'll wish you found sooner | 2 of 10 http://t.co/M9SXbnJS via @zite

Do you have a reference for the 40% in Willunga? The only public figures I've seen are 29% for Willunga and 26% for Kiama. It would cert...

6 hours ago by mathew42 on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

SA Health's journey to ehealth Business News ZDNet Australia: Implementing e-health services for an entire state... http://t.co/QuiOy7OQ

London to become Intel's city-living R&D testbed - ZDNet UK (blog): IT PROLondon to become Intel's city-living R... http://t.co/5qdivDa1

#Google #Australia Much ado about Google's tax http://t.co/DCMsJGyN

RT @zdnetaustralia: NSW outs datacentre deal details: http://t.co/A1Cj4Eot ^LH

by http://t.co/vmlLt4bh: Build your own smartphone stand: Looking for a smartphone stand, but not interested in d... http://t.co/DptVvkoB

Build your own smartphone stand: Looking for a smartphone stand, but not interested in dishing out the dough? We... http://t.co/TgSeZIdM

last couple of hours to submit your application for #crmidol. Step up and take your chance! http://t.co/7vQxdbY3 #scrm #crm #value

The rural Silicon Valley http://t.co/vqV6bl5i

Build your own smartphone stand http://t.co/IY6VxA7n

RT @zdnetaustralia: NSW outs datacentre deal details: http://t.co/A1Cj4Eot ^LH

This story has been voted 12000 times in the last 24 hours!

1 day ago, Is Bill Gates a great leader?

This story has been voted 10 times in the last 24 hours!

3 days ago, CeBIT 2012 opens: photos

This story has been voted 15 times in the last 24 hours!

3 days ago, Lenovo ThinkPad 3G tablet (32GB)

Facebook Activity

Keep up with ZDNet Australia

ZDNet Events Calendar

ZDNet Events Calendar