Is Australia's data retention idea that scary?

Patch Monday

Stilgherrian

Nobody's safe as Stilgherrian turns his laser focus onto Australia's IT industry in a weekly podcast.

Related gallery

CeBIT 2012 opens: photos

CeBIT 2012 opens: photos

Re-tweeted by

Play or download the Patch Monday podcast below:

Download Add to iTunes

Embed podcast:

Is the government really talking about recording all your web browsing? Is the European Directive on Data Retention, which the government is using as an example of what it could adopt, really benign? The idea itself certainly seems scary enough to be part of a privacy inquiry.

As ZDNet Australia has reported previously, the Attorney-General's Department has been holding confidential discussions with internet service providers about the possibility of recording details of your internet usage for later potential use by law enforcement agencies.

While there have been concerns that this could amount to recording web browsing history, the government insists that's not on the agenda, and have been pointing to the European Directive on Data Retention as a model.

So what is this directive? Apparently it's somewhat controversial itself. To explain what it's about we speak with Gunther Bloemen, Practice lead for EMEA with Verizon Business in Brussels. Does it enable the recording of your web browsing? It depends on how you look at it.

Given the questions raised by the government's data retention ruminations and recent privacy problems for Facebook and Google, the Senate has launched a privacy inquiry.

The inquiry by the Senate Standing Committee on Environment, Communications and the Arts is calling for evidence on "the adequacy of protections for the privacy of Australians online". Submissions to the inquiry close 23 July.

It was initiated by the Greens, and on Patch Monday this week Greens Senator Scott Ludlam explains the party's concerns.

Patch Monday also includes Stilgherrian's idiosyncratic look at some of the week's IT news headlines.

To leave an audio comment for Patch Monday, Skype to stilgherrian, or phone Sydney 02 8011 3733.

Running time 26 minutes, 24 seconds

Talkback

Is the government keeping a record of everything you've ever googled scary? Or every webpage youve ever clicked on? So just why do they want to do this? When would it have ever been in the publics interest? I think Australia needs to stand up and say enough is enough.

peternisspeterniss July 6th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

Many people in Aus and Europe seem to be confused about what the governments want. the European / British system is designed for weblogs and emails to be scanned offline for key phrases or words and that would then flag up a warning for the security services. It is primarily an anti-terrorism measure. I can't see why anyone, except criminals and terrorists would be worried. Unless, of course they are doing something illegal on the web.

Johnnyf50Johnnyf50 July 6th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

Johnny, what then stops the next government searching through records for words related to drug use? (Afterall, we all could be drug dealers) Or blasphemy? Or homosexuality? Or Communism? (All were 'in their day' the big threats to society as a whole)

The internet will soon be the centrepiece of the majority of commerce and communication. Soon all telephone calls will be routed through the internet, all bill paying, all banking....etc....is it right that any corporation/government has access to all that? Especially if it is "just in case".

Would you consent to having your home and office bugged to listen to all conversations "just in case"? Would you consent to having a GPS installed to track where and when you go to places "just in case"?

The need for this is tenuous at best - terrorists and criminals already hide as much as possible from governments, thus the sort of data retention they are talking about will likely provide little that would bring down a terrorist cell. Plus all a half clever terrorist needs to do is use codewords and suddenly the bomb planted at parliment house becomes "the flowerpot has been planted at Polly's house, she'll be surprised at 4:30pm."

Finally the kind of data crunching and data storage required for such an analysis is mind boggling both in cost and sheer size. The money would be better spent on funding actual police/undercover agents.

BaggyoneBaggyone July 6th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (+1) (0)

This was the process that Hitler used in the 1930's to incrementally change perceptions and have full control over the population. These are only minor changes. You have nothing to fear if you are a good citizen.
He didn't have the command of communications that modern governments have, and want to expand.
It is almost like George Orwell had written a training manual for future governments.......
'Nuff said!

pilotyodapilotyoda July 25th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

It isn't that it is scary. I would rather that they explain why they need this.

LoftwahLoftwah July 6th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

This is part of a government agenda to enslave the population into intimidation. The goverment has labelled the entire population as criminal. it has an evil agenda and this is nothing short of extremism. This type of surveillance is not warranted on a free world that clearly the government along with corporations seek to destroy. This is part of the new world order globalisation.

riggieriggie July 6th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

It is no longer innocent until proven guilty - you are now guilty until proven innocent!
"The Man who trades freedom for security does not deserve nor will he ever receive either." - Benjamin Franklin

ishnobuishnobu July 6th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

If we ignore it's a government considering this scheme, who can make their own laws, wouldn't this breach the Privacy Act? You're only allowed to collect relevant information, which rules out 90% of the googletubemyface traffic...

Seriously, there's no point spending a fortune to gather huge volumes of data. If it's only going to be used when 'necessary' it's useless 99% of the time. If you're constantly going to mine it then there is too much data to deal with.

Scott WScott W July 7th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)
Add your opinion

In order to post a comment, you need to be registered. (Sign In or register below)

Post your comment

Terms of Service - As a ZDNet registrant, and by using this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understand our Privacy Policy.

ZDNet Australia Live

IT Priorities: servers and storage http://t.co/E1U97jCk

RT @rladvisory: Video - Rob Livingstone @EVOLVECloud 'Getting cloud adoption right' - @zdnetaustralia http://t.co/G6GwvJCp http://t.co/nJrIY3vA @rladvisory

What's happening now with storage and servers? We delved into the area in our IT Priorities webinar series. http://t.co/XmLAsln8 ^ST

RT @rladvisory: ZDNet Video of my recent Executive Keynote presentation delivered at the EVOLVE.Cloud conference entitled...: http://t.co/2h9hEno2

IT Priorities: servers and storage: In November 2011, ZDNet Australia published the results of its IT Priorities... http://t.co/uOxpN90t

IT Priorities: servers and storage http://t.co/iQ6oT7qe

Accelerator targets 'clean-tech' start-ups http://t.co/8kGTxJGp via @zdnetaustralia

Westpac board goes paperless with iPads http://t.co/kdm26Ewr via @zdnetaustralia

Cloud TVRs stop in wake of TV Now ruling http://t.co/2hLRUvt6 via @zdnetaustralia

RT @WauloK: Two cloud-based TV recording services have been suspended after Optus TV Now. http://t.co/VomMRrRs // @techwebcast Beem is dead.

ZDNet Patch Monday ep137 - Removing the anonymity from Anonymous: http://t.co/E6Tn8vJr

ZDNet Patch Monday ep138 - Anonymous 'crippled': where to for hacktivism?: http://t.co/lbKew6Bo

ZDNet Patch Monday ep139 - War talk dominates AusCERT 2012: http://t.co/rUm22Zjm

ZDNet Patch Monday ep135 - iiNet wards off AFACT, but what next?: http://t.co/0xVdYm6i

ZDNet Patch Monday ep136 - Blackhole crimeware as a service here to stay: http://t.co/evnCUlsX

GoogleTV will revolutionize television once viewers understand it http://t.co/c4lEyb3a

Reading this article is like stepping back in time. If I was Paul Berryman I would hang my head in shame. How embarrassing!!! I can’t b...

1 hour ago by MikeSkoey on 30 servers to 7: BUPA redoes virtualisation

Phone cloning, maybe, but bill duplication? Tech-heads give verdict
http://t.co/aw5SNigN
#ozpolitics

The registration sticker provided a visual reminder to the driver to renew regardless of what happened to the renewal letter. The experie...

1 hour ago by dccharron on NSW ditches rego stickers for tech

"xfire: Why is telecommunications being treated different to roads, water and electricity?" Good question, my guess is AUS is far behind...

1 hour ago by ngoctranminh on Five pros and cons of the NBN

“@zdnetaustralia: Is Windows Phone really the third challenger to Android and iOS? http://t.co/Tr7ASra0 ”. It's different but fast and good

Can HP bounce back? http://t.co/TSlWjmrA

Thanks for the response Luke, Given that the quotes are accurate, then the person in charge of the Vic Health App needs to find another j...

1 hour ago by butterflyeffecs on Android fragmentation steers Vic Health

Social business in Australia http://t.co/aBuXFy40 . Australian businesses still laging behind with social business. Time to catch up!

Can Windows Phone bring a new challenge? #WindowsPhone http://t.co/m82nU7hK

Nice analogy. Another factor is whether you can find 50 people with powerful enough weapons. Minassian's argument is essentially that the...

1 hour ago by Mukimu on National Botnet Network coming: Earthwave

RT @digitaltasmania: @ZDNetAustralia #NBN's Tassie upgrade to cost $1.3m http://t.co/1nTbLUJv -Countdown begins for 1st Oppn. MP to misconstrue per unit cost

@ZDNetAustralia #NBN's Tassie upgrade to cost $1.3m http://t.co/1nTbLUJv -Countdown begins for 1st Oppn. MP to misconstrue per unit cost

RT @mosfreshmedia: Start-up accelerator targets cleantech 'Atlassians, BigCommerce' via @zdnetaustralia http://t.co/oho3oQSK @atpinnovations @hamishhawthorn

Can #HP bounce back?: HP's move to cut 27,000 jobs, reinvest in research and development (R&D) and generally get... http://t.co/dlgAhwxb

Can HP bounce back? http://t.co/qLlHB5FV

It's nice to see Tas finally get some decent internet connectivity, for too long Tas has been stooged on decent internet connectivity but...

1 hour ago by Jingles on NBN's Tassie upgrade to cost $1.3 million

Cloud inefficiency - Bad habits are hard to break: Cloud can save you a lot of money - if you use it effectively... http://t.co/oVoNx2na

by http://t.co/vmlLt4bh: Can HP bounce back?: HP's move to cut 27,000 jobs, reinvest in research and development ... http://t.co/EjWWU9O1

Can HP bounce back?: HP's move to cut 27,000 jobs, reinvest in research and development (R&D) and generally get ... http://t.co/KDGewBVH

Can HP bounce back?: HP's move to cut 27,000 jobs, reinvest in research and development (R&D) and generally get ... http://t.co/y2ajlh9V

Three tips for businesses to support connected customers: While the connected home offers benefits to the consum... http://t.co/psgHJelD

#Agedcare 30 servers to 7: BUPA redoes virtualisation: Most IT teams spend 90 per cent of today making sure that... http://t.co/HmVXHRQ7

[plug] #NBN cost-benefit analyses are so 2011 http://t.co/2mRUKI8G @TurnbullMalcolm has forgotten his CBA; sh/would he still do one? #zdnet

Can HP bounce back? http://t.co/LlAUcyYP

Who is Luke Hartsuyker? He must be the Apprentice FUDster. As PaulPC has already said regional consumers want, deserve and are entitled...

2 hours ago by dickster on Regional review highlights NBN, mobile

Three tips for businesses to support connected customers http://t.co/W7Sr3RpD

Its good to see the NBN keeping up with the latest equipement & letting the people benefit from it. After all thats why it was a trial, ...

2 hours ago by fibretech on NBN's Tassie upgrade to cost $1.3 million

Shadow Minister for Regional Communications Luke Hartsuyker has got it wrong. Regional consumers want improved mobile services AND the NB...

3 hours ago by PaulPC on Regional review highlights NBN, mobile

Just remember that Google haven't broken any laws here, they're just doing what all their other multinational competitiors do; minimise t...

3 hours ago by Pachanga on Much ado about Google's tax

ルイヴィトン バッグ : http://www.lovebagjp.com/ Louis Vuitton bags, Louis Vuitton pretension nose about,Louis Vuitton daydre...

4 hours ago by bundLourb on Reservoir blogs: Fan fakes Tarantino diary

シャネル バッグ : http://www.bagssalejp.org/ Chanel trap,chanel shekels,gucci bags,direct purse,poor recent Louis Vuitton keep...

6 hours ago by bybrinkLync on Reservoir blogs: Fan fakes Tarantino diary

I guess but in both cases, dead body!

16 hours ago by Doubt on National Botnet Network coming: Earthwave

I think it's for the very reasons you mention in your first paragraph that there is no CBA. With the ideological differences and vested ...

16 hours ago by RealismBias on NBN cost-benefit analyses are so 2011

Good points; but how do you establish consensus about the terms of reference of a cost-benefit analysis? What is to be included? How far ...

16 hours ago by Gwyntaglaw on NBN cost-benefit analyses are so 2011

I live in a small country town & have done since 2002. When I got to this town it had no mobile phone & no broadband. The only reason w...

17 hours ago by fibretech on Regional review highlights NBN, mobile

Hi there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that it is really informative. I am going to watch out for brussels. I...

17 hours ago by Uttedsips on Fujitsu Stylistic ST5011

Like most things in life, the devil is in the details. If a cost benefit analysis included a societal element, I'm certain nobody on eit...

17 hours ago by RealismBias on NBN cost-benefit analyses are so 2011

The coalition has done nothing else but keep changing their view over the last 2 years. -first it was "there is nothing wrong with the ...

18 hours ago by djz on NBN cost-benefit analyses are so 2011

Use the force Luke... FFS

18 hours ago by Beta on Regional review highlights NBN, mobile

This story has been voted 12000 times in the last 24 hours!

22 hours ago, Is Bill Gates a great leader?

This story has been voted 10 times in the last 24 hours!

2 days ago, CeBIT 2012 opens: photos

This story has been voted 15 times in the last 24 hours!

2 days ago, Lenovo ThinkPad 3G tablet (32GB)

Facebook Activity

Keep up with ZDNet Australia

ZDNet Events Calendar

ZDNet Events Calendar