Bridging the data storage divide
NAS gateways, also known as NAS heads, are one way to combine the best of both NAS and SAN. These products offer greater ability to add capacity compared with a traditional, self-contained NAS storage system, said Jim Holley, EMC's director of NAS platforms. "If you start out with an appliance, eventually you're going to outgrow that appliance," he said.
Using NAS heads also allows companies to tap into unused capacity on SANs. And the products permit customers to trim the number of administrators needed to manage storage, said John McArthur, an analyst at market research firm IDC. McArthur said companies now have the option of replacing multiple NAS devices with a NAS head that links to a large-capacity SAN system. "If you want to simplify your environment, you want to consolidate," he said. "It increases 'vendor lock-in,' but it brings down operational costs."
In mentioning vendor lock-in, McArthur highlighted the limited compatibility of NAS gateway products. For example, Network Appliance said its NAS gateway products work with SAN equipment from Hitachi Data Systems and IBM, but not EMC's. IBM's NAS Gateway 300 works only with IBM's FastT storage servers and Enterprise Storage Server products. EMC's NAS gateway products are compatible only with EMC storage systems.
Aside from NAS gateways, another approach to bridging NAS and SAN technologies is to allow for both "block"- and "file"-level data access in the same device. This is a route Network Appliance has taken with its so-called unified storage products. Since 2002, the company has offered disk-based storage devices that allow for both block- and file-level data access.
More and more customers are using the products to handle data in both ways, said Chris Bennett, director of product marketing at NetApp. "It's common, and it's becoming even more common," he said.
A big, big file system
Still, another means to connect the SAN and NAS worlds is through technology that essentially creates a file system for SANs. For instance, IBM's SAN File System -- launched last year -- is designed to tie together servers in multiple locations over an Internet Protocol network and then allow the SAN to look and behave like a local file system, no matter where the data resides. Software keeps track of descriptive information, or "metadata," such as physical locations, file sizes and access permissions, that accompanies the actual content within the files, IBM said.
SAN File System is part of IBM's broader "on demand" computing initiative, which aims in part to provide information technology systems that smoothly handle spikes in usage. Sun Microsystems and Hewlett-Packard are working on related efforts.
IBM's SAN File System is more complicated to put in place than a typical NAS box. SAN File System software runs on metadata servers dedicated to it. In addition, software has to be installed on other servers using the system. But Big Blue said that the product can manage petabytes of data -- one petabyte is equivalent to a million and a half CDs, IBM said.
"This is the ultimate of that (NAS-SAN) convergence," said Jeff Barnett, manager of marketing strategy for IBM's storage software unit. "A single NAS box is not going to scale to petabytes of data."
Perhaps not, but BlueArc said its new Titan product allows for up to 12 units to be clustered together for a total system capacity of 3 petabytes. Key to making its NAS products act like a SAN is the use of programmable silicon chips, according the company. BlueArc integrates a number of tasks usually reserved for software -- such as protocols and network services -- into so-called field-programmable gate arrays. That provides a speed boost that allows customers to run database programs or other applications that frequently use a block-level approach without a performance penalty, the company said.
"The distinction between SAN and NAS is blurred to some degree," said Geoff Barrall, chief technical officer at BlueArc.
The new Titan product has an architecture that will permit businesses to upgrade the speed of the product from 5gbps to an eventual 20gbps. What's more, the Titan supports larger file systems -- up to 256 terabytes in a single file system -- which can make for easier storage management, BlueArc said.
Two other smaller players in the storage world, Isilon Systems and Panasas, also have NAS products that are designed to let companies easily increase data capacity.
Although the NAS-SAN crossover has begun, the trend will increase with the emergence of iSCSI, Cox said. iSCSI is an interface technology that allows SANs to be built using less-expensive Ethernet networks. Another possible catalyst is the evolution of Ethernet bandwidth, which is expected to increase to 10gbps within the next couple of years, Cox said.
"Then you've got Ethernet on the same playing field as Fibre Channel," he said. "That's when all that gets real interesting."
10%
8%
