Who's afraid of the $200 Linux PC?

By Erica Ogg, CNET News.com
25 January 2008 02:06 PM
Tags: asus, everex, shuttle, mirus, linux, eee pc, ubuntu, o'grady

Cheap PCs with a Linux operating system seem to have hit users' sweet spots, with taking the plunge into the alternate OS now considered not nearly as difficult as users had thought.

Linux is not just for computer whizzes. In fact, buying Linux and learning how to use it are easier than ever, thanks to the open source operating system's expanding presence in affordable computers and mainstream retail outlets.

In quick succession, the number of mass market, sub US$200 desktops has tripled -- from one to three -- in less than three months. At the Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas earlier this month, small form-factor PC maker Shuttle debuted its US$199 KPC. The catch? It's not preloaded with Windows, but an operating system based on Linux. Then last week, Mirus and Linspire collaborated on the Mirus Linux PC, which is now for sale at Sears.com. It's US$299 (although an included US$100 rebate brings it to US$199), and is preloaded with Freespire 2.0, an Ubuntu-based Linux distribution.

Want to know more?

For all the latest news, analysis and opinion on Linux, click here

But the beginning of the low cost computer trend actually started last spring. The Everex gPC showed up on the shelves of Wal-Mart for US$198, a low price even for a desktop PC. It's bundled with speakers, a mouse, and a keyboard, and it comes with 24 hour tech support. The operating system is called gOS, a version of Ubuntu 7.10. Sure, that may be almost unpronounceable for most average consumers, but despite that, Wal-Mart is having trouble keeping the gPC in stock.

Linux is getting more mainstream exposure than just appearing in inexpensive computers. It's now being offered by two of the world's largest PC manufacturers, Dell and Lenovo, and is making its way into tiny -- not to mention trendy -- inexpensive laptops, like One Laptop Per Child's XO, Everex's CloudBook, and Asus' Eee PC, all of which come with Linux preinstalled. In the case of the Eee, it is doing surprisingly well with consumers.

So what are we to think now that Linux, long popular among a very narrow niche of computer users, is making its way to mainstream retail outlets? Perhaps that trying a US$200 Linux PC isn't as risky as some might think. Here are five reasons why.

Lower barrier to entry
At US$200, that's not a huge penalty for trying an unfamiliar operating system packaged by a hardware company you may not have heard of before. Just to put it in proper perspective, US$199 is less than half the price of an iPhone, and is roughly equivalent to about five percent of the cost of a new decent-quality 32-inch high-definition TV or five to six tanks of petrol. If you don't have a ton of expendable income, you can always put off updating your current Windows or Mac machine for six months, try it out, and see what you think.

Preinstalled is perfect for newbies
True, the biggest headache associated with most versions of Linux these days is the actual installation, but that's the case for any operating system, Stephen O'Grady, principal analyst for Redmonk, points out. Installing Windows from scratch on a machine can hit snags just as much as installing a version of Linux. But, he added: "If you're getting it preinstalled, the manufacturer has done the legwork to make sure the individual parts in the machine work with the operating system involved." All of that can translate to fewer headaches for the user.

And maintenance is relatively easy. That's because most versions of Linux come with package management. Unlike Windows, which just updates the operating system itself, Ubuntu, for example, will update the OS plus any of the applications included. "The average everyday user doesn't have to do anything," O'Grady said.

Familiarity breeds loyalty
Linux is getting easier to use all the time -- and better looking. The past two years have seen the most consistent leaps in the improvement of the user interface. In the last year alone, 3D desktop effects -- a la Windows Vista and Mac OS X -- have been introduced.

"There has been some effort in recent years to make the transition more comfortable by mimicking some of the user conventions of Windows or Mac OS," said O'Grady. For instance, a "Start" menu or an applications "dock." The Everex Green PC runs gOS, whose desktop looks strikingly similar to Mac OS X.

The specs are acceptable for general use
All of the companies making sub US$200 Linux machines -- Everex, Shuttle, and Mirus -- use brand-name parts you've heard of: Intel processors and chipsets; ATI graphics cards; and more. Mirus' and Shuttle's Linux PCs come with a minimum of 1GB of memory, and Everex's comes with 512MB, upgradable to 2GB. All three have an 80GB hard drive, enough to do basic computing tasks. It should be noted that none of the offerings is a complete PC, however. The gPC and the Mirus lack a monitor, and the Shuttle comes with nothing but the PC.

The Web browser is your friend
It sounds simple, but most of what the average user wants to do with a computer these days can be done online: word processing, spreadsheets, e-mail, photo editing, and more, which means less storage is less of an issue. You want e-mail? Gmail and the included GTalk instant messaging feature are free. And Google's Docs and Spreadsheets Web apps get all of your office productivity done online (though most of the three PCs have open source versions of Microsoft Office). For watching videos, there's YouTube and Hulu.com. And rather than downloading a photo editing tool, anyone can upload their photos to Flickr and use Picnik's editing software right in the browser.

The success of devices like the gPC and Mirus Freespire -- both are sold out at Wal-Mart and Sears.com, respectively -- and even the more expensive and portable Eee PC, is a surprise to most.

"The success is, in part, driven by the fact that for people doing an increasing percentage of day-to-day tasks like e-mail in the context of software as a service, at that point it soon doesn't matter what operating system you have," said Redmonk's O'Grady. "If a majority of [computer] usage is browsing the Internet and doing things like that, [Linux] is perfectly credible, perfectly usable."

Advertisement

Talkback 4 comments

    Who's afraid of the $200 Linux PC? Anonymous -- 25/01/08

    But who's to say that the people buying these cheap PCs are actually keeping Linux and not just installing Windows over the top?

    A cheap PC and an illegal copy of Windows would explain the popularity of such machines.

    Who's afraid of the $200 Linux PC ricardo -- 26/01/08 (in reply to #320094326)

    As much as you may want to think that Linux get's wiped off the HDD I think you are totally mistaken.

    Let's look at the facts:
    A) No Virus Problems
    B) No Spyware Issues
    C) No having to reinstall windows every 2x months.

    I know that there are good reasons why the Microsoft industry would love to ban Linux from the general public, on the one hand, the 'Microsoft Click Money' IT support staff have to re-skill & actually learn something new, only to be rewarded with less work cause Linux PCs are more stable & break less than M$ Windows PCs (No M$ Virus/tROJAN/sPYWARE problems) & fewer reinstalls as a result of using a superior OS like Linux.

    On the other hand, Microsoft wants to ban Linux cause they know too well that they will sell Less of It's M$Office & Windows, every 100x win reinstalls equals to extra users who lost their M$Office install Product Id & have to resort to buying a new package of M$ Office, more $$$ for M$.

    And we all know that OpenOffice Suite is Free & unlocked & is totally comaptible with all M$Office standards. I wonder how long Microsoft & it's fanboys can keep try to hide the truth frokm the general public?

    Competition is not such a bad thing, M$ will try to pretend there is competition in the OS/Office market but the truth is that they have so far managed to shut down debate on this very important subject about freedom in how we store & manage our own data, they own Media & have an army of Paid Mouths out there, day & night, they can't sleep while they know that Linux is out there. Beware of the M$ paid posters' misleading FUD campaigns. they have a lot of $$$ to loose.

    Linux is the way forward Anonymous -- 25/04/08 (in reply to #320094326)

    Cheap, reliable, looks better, even easier to use and install. Recommended by systems administrators.

    Who's afraid of the $200 Linux PC? Anonymous -- 22/10/08 (in reply to #320094326)

    Yes People may want to wipe out linux with windows, you are right. But can u imagine the performance that linux will deliver compared to windows? Budd, PC will hang every 10 mns and restart will be needed.. People don't use linux becuase they are afraid to chage... nothing else....

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

1) Apple iPhone 3GS 32GB36 plans 6%
2) Apple iPhone 3GS 16GB30 plans 1%
3) Apple iPhone 8GB42 plans 1%
4) HTC Magic16 plans 2%
5) Nokia N9743 plans 1%

Mobiles | Broadband | Credit Cards

ZDNET Australia Partner Services

Blogs

  • Darren Greenwood Telecom NZ savings damage prospects
    If Telecom NZ wants to have any of the NZ$1.5 billion the government intends to spend on its new broadband network, it had better think long and hard before offshoring 1500 jobs.
  • Array iiNet: The whys and what nows
    Last week the Federal Court ruled that internet service providers are not responsible for copyright violation by their customers. This is an important decision not just for iiNet, which spent around $4 million defending the case, but for all ISPs in Australia and, indeed, globally.
  • Array Govt, hurry up with releasing data
    A programmer scraped data from the My School website to make some really cool heat maps showing regions of smart schools — no thanks to the government, which didn't supply the data in any useful kind of format.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured