Virtual privacy: Eight VPN appliances tested

Specifications

Product Contivity 1100 CyberGuard SG575 Firebox 1000 Fortigate 60
Company Nortel Networks BAX IT SERVICES Pty Ltd Watchguard Technologies, Inc Fortinet
Price (inc GST) US$1499 US (approx AU$2001) AU$1829 AU$5060 AU$1300 includes first year's maintenance, AV and IPS updates
Warranty 1 year, 90-day software support 1-year warranty (standard), optional four-year warranty. 1 year 1 year
Certifications Common Criteria ELA4, DSD ISCA, VPNC, VPNC ICSA IPSEC and firewall, EAL4 due for completion early 2005 ICSA
Encryption standards supported DES, 3DES, AES, RC4 DES, 3DES, AES DES, 3DES (AES in Hardware) DES, 3DES, AES128, AES192, AES256
Ethernet ports internal 4 1 or 2 5 4
Ethernet ports external 1 1 or 2 1 2
Other Ports Optional additional 10/100BaseT Ethernet Single-port V.35/X.21 T1 with integrated CS+B41U/DSU V.90 dial modem Serial Serial, HDD bracket 1 x DMZ
Reporting methods (log, email notification, custom tools) Internal Log, SYS, SNMP, Syslog, e-mail for some functions, SNMP, Cerberian Log, e-mail, custom tools Internal & external logging, Alert e-mail, SNMP traps
# tunnels 30 400 1500 40 dedicated, unlimited from VPN client
VPN 3DES speed (Mbps) 15Mb/s 20Mbps 75Mbps 20Mbps
Target market SOHO/SME SME SME SOHO and SMB
Other features   SNORT, SQUID, NASL. Deep packet inspection, intrusion prevention, spam filtering, Web blocking, gateway AV, model upgradeability ASIC based, integrated stateful firewall, AV, antiSpam, intrusion prevention, content filtering, traffic shaping, 802.1Q VLANs, high availability, L2TP & PPTP VPNs, quad ICSA certified


Product FVL328 NS-5GT/ NS-5GT ADSL Pro 2040 SGS 400
Company Netgear Juniper Networks SonicWall Symantec
Price (inc GST) AU$1069 AU$927/ AU$1073t US$3495 (approx $4665 AUD) as supplied with Enhanced Operating System from AU$899
Warranty 3-years limited 1 year 1 year 1 year
Certifications ICSA, VPNC ICSA firewall and VPN ICSA NA
Encryption standards supported DES, 3DES DES, 3DES, AES DES, 3DES, AES DES, 3DES, AES
Ethernet ports internal 8 5 (+ 1xADSL) 1 8
Ethernet ports external 1 software configurable 3 (configurable) 2
Other Ports 8-Port 10/100 switch Console, modem Serial Serial, dip switches
Reporting methods (log, email notification, custom tools) Syslog Syslog (up to 4 servers) e-mail (2 addresses) NetIQ Webtrends SNMPv2 Traceroute Syslog, local log, SNMP trap, e-mail, Global Management System (GMS) Syslog
# tunnels 100 up to 10 max 100 50*
VPN 3DES speed (Mbps) 15.7Mbps 20Mbps 50Mbps 35Mbps
Target market SOHO and Corporate Remote office SOHO, SMB Small- to mid- sized networks (up to 200 nodes) SME
Other features High-speed 150-MHz CPU for fast tunnelling throughput. True firewall with stateful packet inspection (SPI) and intrusion detection denial of service (DoS) attack protection. Stateful firewall (2000 sessions), Network/Port Address Translation, IPSec NAT Traversal Redundant VPN Gateways VPN Tunnel Monitoring OSPF, BGP, RIPv2, Static Routes, and more Enhanced OS (as supplied) provides wireless access with Sonic Points (IPSEC enforcable), Wireless Guest Services.Plus optionals. Firewall anti-virus Policy enforcement intrusion detection/ prevention content filtering hardware add-on wireless LAN access point

Advertisement

Talkback 0 comments

Back to top

Featured