commentary Mobile World Congress is such a terrible, terrible tease. Every year we see those shiny new handsets in the hands of the lucky few who get to attend the show in Barcelona, and then we're forced to wait six months before we have them in our eager hands.
This year promises a few tasty treats, like Samsung's Omnia HD and the Sony Ericsson Idou, but in terms of sheer potential, none compare to the Palm Pre. US company Palm is dragging itself out of the grave with this release and from what we've seen so far, the Pre is not only the phone Palm needed to make, but it's also the phone we've been waiting for.
The head-to-head comparisons with Apple's iPhone are too obvious to ignore, particularly the unique touchscreen interfaces used in each of these smartphones. A quick caveat before we toss these fierce competitors in the ring: the specs listed for the Pre are not final, and the specs listed for the iPhone may change considerably with the release of a rumoured successor mid-year. Be sure, we'll update this table as soon as any new information comes to light.
Platform: OSX vs. webOS
OSX is the at once the great strength and weakness of the iPhone. On the one hand you have a super stable platform that provides an excellent user experience, plus it's apparently very easy to write software for the iPhone (as 31 iFart applications will attest to). At the same time, this stable and speedy performance is due in part to the iPhone not being capable of multitasking or having applications running in the background.
Palm's Card system is the exact antithesis of this, not only running several applications in the background, but showing them in an active state on the deck-of-cards style home screen. This way you can have messages sent from IM services or social networking sites sent to your phone while you type emails, surf the web or take a phone call.
Another fascinating software implementation is what Palm is calling Synergy, referring to the way webOS deals with the various different communication methods we use to converse with the one person. Firstly, a contact's information listing contains all their addresses and numbers; phone, email, IM addresses, social networking aliases (like Facebook). While the iPhone and Windows Mobile phones may thread consecutive SMS messages together into a conversation, the Pre will be able to thread cross-platform communication together. For example, you'll be able to reply to a Gmail message with an SMS or an IM over Windows Live.
For all these ingenious advancements, the iPhone will still have the Pre beat in the sheer number of third-party applications available on the Apple App Store. Palm has announced its intention to launch a similar one-stop-shop for downloading apps to the Pre, but at launch it should still be a long way behind the 15,000+ apps available for iPhone.
Perhaps it's the allure of the new and shiny, but Palm's Pre is our new tech crush, and it leaves the iPhone looking like an old maid. The hands-on videos we've seen show an interface as responsive, if not more responsive, than the iPhone's and the combination of the Cards and Synergy system far outshines the linear tree-structure of input into Apple's phone. It really looks like the iPhone but better.
That said, there are so many variables and unknowns that could quickly shift our opinion of the Pre. Battery life and the way it plays with other devices, like PCs, are two concerns that immediately spring to mind. Part of the strength of the iPhone is the ease with which it syncs files from your computer to the phone, but something tells us Palm won't overlook this.
Talkback 1 comments
Head to head: iPhone 3GS vs Palm Pre? Anonymous -- 22/06/09
Reader Services
Popular Topics
Essentials
- Broadband Plan Finder
Not sure which broadband plan to choose? Try our Broadband Plan Finder. - Best laptops
Check out the best laptops here! - Mobile Phone Plan Finder
Pick the best mobile phone plan deal with our Mobile Phone Plan Finder. - Broadband speedtest
How fast is your Internet connection? Calculate the speed here.
Sponsored Links
- Having problems with complex data center? – Simplify now with Intel® Unified Networking Solutions
- Australia IT Salary & Skills Report 2009 – Join activeTechPros for free access
- BSA video competition – Get creative and win great prizes. Find out more.
- Fuji Xerox – 0% finance on the latest Fuji Xerox A3 Colour Multifunction Devices. Conditions apply
- TPG ADSL2+ Broadband – 100 GB for $49.99 per month. Sign up now.
Featured
What makes you click?
Tell us for a chance to win a $1,000 GAME gift voucher.
Click here for more.
Win an iPhone 3GS!
Sign up as a ZDNet Australia member during November and you'll go in a draw to win an iPhone 3GS! Click here to sign up!
Best Laptops
Check out the best laptops here!
Click here for more.
- ZDNet International
Any updates to this article, now the the 3GS is shipping? Many of your comparisons are no longer up to date.