Google fined for offering Maps for free

You may like that Google Maps is free, but a French court says it's actually anti-competitive.

(Screenshot by Don Reisinger/CNET)

A Paris court earlier this week ordered Google France and its parent company Google to pay plaintiff Bottin Cartographes €500,000 for providing its free mapping services to businesses across the country. The court also required Google to pay a €15,000 fine for its practice.

"We proved the illegality of [Google's] strategy to remove its competitors," Jean-David Scemmama, attorney for Bottin Cartographes, a company that provides mapping services to businesses, told the AFP in an interview earlier this week. "The court recognised the unfair and abusive character of the methods used, and allocated Bottin Cartographes all it claimed. This is the first time Google has been convicted for its Google Maps application."

According to Scemmama, Bottin has been arguing its case against Google for two years, claiming the search giant was engaging in anti-competitive practices by using its free service to take control over the online-mapping industry.

In a statement to the AFP, Google said that it will appeal the court's decision, adding that Google Maps is still facing competition in that market.

Late last year, Google Maps also came under fire in the US, after British Telecom filed a lawsuit against the search giant in a Delaware District Court, claiming the mapping service violates patents it holds related to navigation information.

Google did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the Maps lawsuit.

Via CNET

Talkback

Wow, now we get to sue companies for providing a free service! Bring it on!

In all seriousness though, companies CAN compete with Google Maps quite easily. Just provide something Google does not. In the satellite imagery stakes, Nearmap does it here. They do so by providing MUCH newer images (usually no more than a month old), a very intuitive time slider (see your house being built/check shading on your roof for solar panel installation etc.), and things like measuring tools (again for measuring roof space for installations etc.).

None of this Google does or does well. Hence my previous company I worked for paid for Nearmap services. Well worth it too.

RamrunnerRamrunner February 6th, 2012
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

Microsoft now can sue LibreOffice in France for its unfair competition against MSOffice :)

golimpiogolimpio February 7th, 2012
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)
Add your opinion

In order to post a comment, you need to be registered. (Sign In or register below)

Post your comment

Terms of Service - As a ZDNet registrant, and by using this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understand our Privacy Policy.

ZDNet Australia Live

An excellent reflection of the issues in the Google vs Oracle lawsuit. http://t.co/lh5BiHr9

NSW ditches rego stickers for tech - Business - News - ZDNet Australia http://t.co/7d7nKzTc

“@ZDNet: Logitech Solar Keyboard Folio for iPad: No sun required (review) http://t.co/l9S3t2tJ” #fb

Researchers intercept Tatanga malware bypassing SMS based transaction authorization http://t.co/QFuFWOkq

RT @ZDNet Would an accelerator just for clean tech companies work? http://t.co/rsawucUi
> they don't all have long lead times!

Telstra GameArena gets hacked, 35k accounts stolen, lets hope the passwords were hashed properly http://t.co/4xMi1DBR

RT @erucsbo: #Kaspersky denied #iOS app: #Apple buries its head in the #security sand http://t.co/4ANNtZ1F

Cloud TVRs stop in wake of TV Now ruling - http://t.co/VCviX6NP

Optus uses Singapore to boost cloud #Cloud #singapore http://t.co/AqMiBgfM

NBN cost-benefit analyses are so 2011: It wasn't too long ago that one of the rallying cries of the Coalition's ... http://t.co/5hZlPIpF

Regional review highlights NBN, mobile: Poor mobile coverage across the nation is the biggest telecommunications... http://t.co/ejFFqqzC

I guess but in both cases, dead body!

2 hours ago by Doubt on National Botnet Network coming: Earthwave

@wenhwu And two ZDNet articles ;)

I think it's for the very reasons you mention in your first paragraph that there is no CBA. With the ideological differences and vested ...

3 hours ago by RealismBias on NBN cost-benefit analyses are so 2011

Yay! RT @lukehopewell: NSW abolishes rego stickers: http://t.co/QGeepgmf

Optus uses Singapore to boost #cloud: Optus has announced changes to its enterprise cloud suite, which will alig... http://t.co/SdQwsoNu

cool RT @joshgnosis: Cool, NSW Govt to ditch rego stickers for cars. http://t.co/0qWEZ48p

Privacy Act amendments hit parliament: http://t.co/evSFcY1D

Google didn't infringe on Oracle patents: jury http://t.co/rbUpPtDI

Good points; but how do you establish consensus about the terms of reference of a cost-benefit analysis? What is to be included? How far ...

3 hours ago by Gwyntaglaw on NBN cost-benefit analyses are so 2011

Regional review highlights NBN, mobile: Poor mobile coverage across the nation is the biggest telecommunications... http://t.co/4xoofIHY

NBN cost-benefit analyses are so 2011: (Image by US Navy, public domain) On the first point, he is correct: Labo... http://t.co/WP2DDH0L

Optus uses Singapore to boost cloud http://t.co/4KweZf4Z

RT @zdnetaustralia: Optus leverages Singapore to boost cloud http://t.co/yaKRDILg ^ML

I live in a small country town & have done since 2002. When I got to this town it had no mobile phone & no broadband. The only reason w...

4 hours ago by fibretech on Regional review highlights NBN, mobile

Optus uses Singapore to boost cloud - ZDNet Australia http://t.co/uBjaFdZq

Optus uses Singapore to boost cloud: Optus has announced changes to its enterprise cloud suite, which will align... http://t.co/nvXHO4Vc

“@ZDNet: The curse of free cloud services: a cautionary tale http://t.co/UsX7fIyl” Lessons to learn for not only user but developers!

Telco regional review becomes a political tug of war http://t.co/Hm2jfVdN ^ST

Hi there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that it is really informative. I am going to watch out for brussels. I...

4 hours ago by Uttedsips on Fujitsu Stylistic ST5011

Optus uses Singapore to boost cloud - ZDNet Australia http://t.co/SuNgy86q

Optus uses Singapore to boost cloud - ZDNet Australia http://t.co/mj4ou8W4

Like most things in life, the devil is in the details. If a cost benefit analysis included a societal element, I'm certain nobody on eit...

4 hours ago by RealismBias on NBN cost-benefit analyses are so 2011

Optus uses Singapore to boost cloud - ZDNet Australia: iTWireOptus uses Singapore to boost cloudZDNet AustraliaO... http://t.co/bchZXTe5

Regional review highlights NBN, mobile - ZDNet Australia: iTWireRegional review highlights NBN, mobileZDNet Aust... http://t.co/3ciPt00F

Optus uses Singapore to boost cloud - ZDNet Australia: iTWireOptus uses Singapore to boost cloudZDNet AustraliaT... http://t.co/9N7AKfe4

Optus uses Singapore to boost cloud - ZDNet Australia http://t.co/1lPxYVBu

RT @sidhenz: The new @MDSNZ courses come up for some lively discussion on @ZDNetAustralia http://t.co/L4TOpTtL

Optus uses Singapore to boost cloud - ZDNet Australia http://t.co/V988brWP

Optus uses Singapore to boost cloud - ZDNet Australia http://t.co/MgDUJCKm #australia #technews

Yay! About bloody time too RT @zdnetaustralia: NSW ditches registration stickers in favour of technology: http://t.co/68RPK1xL ^LH

The coalition has done nothing else but keep changing their view over the last 2 years. -first it was "there is nothing wrong with the ...

5 hours ago by djz on NBN cost-benefit analyses are so 2011

Use the force Luke... FFS

5 hours ago by Beta on Regional review highlights NBN, mobile

michael kors outlet http://www.michael-kors-discount.com/#5923

5 hours ago by michael kors bag on Best iPhone travel apps

Hey butterflyeffecs and lex, Sorry you're not fans of this piece. But you're dead right in that it is the thoughts and experience of a se...

5 hours ago by LHopewell on Android fragmentation steers Vic Health

teen cams
http://www.aloe-vera.cz handjob

5 hours ago by MyncWenry on Fusion-io ioDrive (80GB)

We have fashional replica bags designer .Replica luxury bags sale here are perfect compromise of quality and price. The replica handbags ...

5 hours ago by Machelle on Telecom NZ CEO Paul Reynolds to leave

It's not a question of whether anyone at HSU would know how to do this, but whether they would have connections with people who could. T...

5 hours ago by meski on CT, phone clone

Fred, I can tell you what the difference between FTTN and FTTH is. FTTH means we will be developing technology and services that we sell ...

5 hours ago by andye on NBN FUD: will Abbott ever learn?

You are 100% right – Abbott is a paragon of tenacity. Now if he could only try that hard to get Malcolm Turnbull's phone number, we co...

6 hours ago by braue on NBN FUD: will Abbott ever learn?

Very interesting to hear Ben and thanks for providing some real-world examples. I suspect the NBN has actually improved things for a grea...

6 hours ago by braue on NBN FUD: will Abbott ever learn?

Hi Geoff, my opening paragraph simply suggests that the leader of the opposition party would rightfully be turning to his communications ...

6 hours ago by braue on NBN FUD: will Abbott ever learn?

Very good point Richard – perhaps one of the most interesting things about this whole debate is how extensively it feeds the collective...

6 hours ago by braue on NBN FUD: will Abbott ever learn?

Yes. I also wonder how much of this intentional subterfuge is actually playing out as part of Turnbull's master plan. Given the rough ri...

7 hours ago by braue on NBN FUD: will Abbott ever learn?

Westpac Management runs STG IT since the take over and it is they Westpac who makes the decisions.

7 hours ago by jeff_syd on St George opts to keep 200 IT workers

This story has been voted 12000 times in the last 24 hours!

8 hours ago, Is Bill Gates a great leader?

This story has been voted 10 times in the last 24 hours!

2 days ago, CeBIT 2012 opens: photos

This story has been voted 15 times in the last 24 hours!

2 days ago, Lenovo ThinkPad 3G tablet (32GB)

Facebook Activity

Keep up with ZDNet Australia

ZDNet Events Calendar

ZDNet Events Calendar