Aussie IT unions rise from the dead

By Renai LeMay, ZDNet.com.au
28 August 2008 02:28 PM
Tags: actu, apesma, eds, ibm, julia gillard, telstra, unions, asg
renai-lemay-zdnet-australia

ZDNet.com.au
news editor
Renai LeMay

commentary Australia's creaky technology unions have finally awoken from their long slumber and have started to throw their weight around.

Like decaying mummies sleeping in an ancient Egyptian tomb, the likes of the Association of Professional Engineers, Scientists and Managers, Australia and the Australian Services Union have languished for the past decade under the odious yoke of the Howard government.

Sure, they have emerged briefly on select occasions over the years to grope blindly towards the management of titans like EDS. APESMA's kerfuffle with the Texan giant back in 2005 was a solid example of the fact that the unions weren't quite dead.

Some, like the Communications Electrical and Plumbers Union, have also been fighting a running battle with Telstra as the opening up of the telecommunications market in 1997 has meant the nation's largest telco has had to continually take the scalpel to large sections of its workforce.

But by and large they've gradually sunk deeper and deeper into obscurity until most local technology reporters would have had a hard time remembering the last time they spoke to a real, live union representative.

The problem has been particularly evident as the ICT industry has gotten back on its feet after the dotcom bust in the early years of this decade. It's a simple mathematical equation: as salaries and job satisfaction rise, enthusiasm for unions fade away.

Eventually people give up and join conservative associations like the Australian Computer Society.

However, the dark Howard years are at an end, and Australia's technology industry is now in a new era: one in which top-level government officials such as Labor Deputy Prime Minister Julia Gillard are willing to back the unions in their disputes with giant corporations.

Gillard's comments to Telstra earlier this month when Telstra tried to push its luck with Howard's doomed Work Choices legislation should have left the telco in no doubt as to the kind of new environment in which it was operating.

"I don't think it is in [Telstra's] interest to be trying to squeeze the last bit of bitter lemon out of Work Choices," Rudd's second in charge said, adding the planned new industrial relations model would be fair and balanced.

"It will certainly say to Telstra and to other companies that if a majority of the employees want to try collectively bargaining, then the employer has to join them at the bargaining table and have a go at it in good faith," Gillard told ABC Television.

Then there's the potential strike action looming over IBM's head at a key Baulkham Hills facility. A recent ZDNet.com.au story about the issue attracted quite a lot of attention.

Big Blue's spin team has been in full flight, attempting to reassure the press that nothing is really going on, but we've heard the union action is all IBM staffers can talk about in water cooler discussions around the nation.

Fair enough, HP's ambitious EDS move has not yet roused workers at the Texan giant's Australian operation, but we expect that slumbering beast to raise its head shortly: perhaps when the "moves, adds and changes" begin?

Lastly, the Communication Workers Union of Australia has certainly made its presence felt in the final death throes of ailing local firm — and Telstra offspring — Commander.

All of this adds up to a disturbing picture for Australian technology managers. It's already an industry constrained by labour shortages, and if the unions get involved in more negotiations, finding and keeping the right staff for less than a king's ransom could become an even greater problem.

It's certainly a nightmare scenario that fast-growing challenger IT services firms like SMS Management and Technology, UXC, ASG and Oakton would be well-advised to keep a close eye on.

IBM, EDS and Telstra already have decades of experience in dealing with unions, and sometimes breaking them. Likewise with mammoth IT departments operated by the likes of the Commonwealth Bank.

Younger firms — and there is a plethora of them — along with smaller IT departments and telcos, need to consider how increased unionisation could affect their ability to do business.

On the flip side, it's a great time to be a non-management IT professional of any shape or size. You're probably already getting paid through the wazoo, you can work from home or part-time, and with the unions by your side, things are only likely to get better. Party on, comrade.

What do you think about IT unions ... a waste of time or a godsend to tech workers? Post your comments below.

Talkback 10 comments

    IT Unions Anonymous -- 28/08/08

    FINALLY, the real IT representative bodies are emerging in the absence of any real support from the ACS, whos only agenda is to flood the market with cheap labour and pander to the Company and Govt interests ahead of its members.

    Supporting the industry starts with supporting your members ACS, not trying to get more Grads by perpetuating the (SKILLS SHORTAGE MYTH) to increase UNI numbers, or increasing immigration and other means of flooding the market.

    The ACS is promoting more membership so it can get more membership fees, and enable the UNI's to get handouts grants from the Govt for IT course to fill jobs that dont and wont exist.

    Hopefully the Unions can fill the void left by the impotent ACS.

    Rubbish Anonymous -- 29/08/08

    I hav been a member of labour unions in the past and when the crunch really comes down they leave all their member flapping unless it will line the pockets of the union bosses.
    Unless that matter involves a majority of workers they dont care.

    Doesnt matter the union or industry; unions are bad value for money and even worse for progress.

    IT does not need a union, nor does it need the kind of human trash that unionism brings (the membership fee grabbing mentality and stand-over tactics).
    I work in govt and the union stop all form of positive progress and have been holding back govt workers for years.

    Screw unions and this union led govt.

    how bout a cleanup too? not happy techie -- 29/08/08

    How about also cleaning up the industry of alot of bad back yarder IT people who really shouldnt be fixing pc's as well as ensure people fixing pc's are certified.

    make TAFE cert's really count in jobs as well as provide more training positions for tafe people. TAFE is the place to go companies if you want employees. train them and they shall come.

    without a forced percentage of australian trained workers we will always be outsourcing to other countries as well as importing people to handle the positions. why not force alot of the cronically unemployed (ie severe doll bludgers) to get a job for once.

    We are powerful Anonymous -- 29/08/08

    ICT workers are some of the most powerful workers in terms of "industrial muscle". If we decide to stick together and act together or even get organised and join unions we can be powerful. I think this is something we will all learn fast. The sooner we join unions with guts like the IBM workers with the ASU the better

    I AGREE Anonymous -- 30/08/08 (in reply to #320110907)

    This is true. ICT workewrs are some of the most powerfull AND influential workers since they operate in a enabling capacity for a wide range of services in all sectors. So together they can become a formidable force.

    Idiots Anonymous -- 02/09/08 (in reply to #320110930)

    I don't suppose you idiots have figured out what you're talking about: Extortion.
    You're basically talking up your ability to hold your employer to ransom.
    To re-iterate: You're well paid with the ability to work from home. You have nothing to strike over.
    So go ahead, strike you idiots. It'll be the death of IT in this country. In case you haven't noticed, the same cables that allow you to work from home also allow Indians to work from home.

    Unions! daryn -- 30/08/08

    "I don't think it is in [Telstra's] interest to be trying to squeeze the last bit of bitter lemon out of Work Choices," Julia Gillard was wrong in saying that misled statement! and for zdnet to provide support to it!, telstra was exercising its legal right against the skullduggery of the unions trying to erode workers rights with illegal side agreements that didnt pertain to workers rights at all! telstra was right to end the 'negotiations' (if you call what the union was doing negotiation) and seperatley pursue their own avenue of securing workers right with a generous 12.5% pay rise over 3 yrs, all while retaining the benifits important to our employees

    Unions! Dave Hollands -- 18/10/08 (in reply to #320110934)

    Daryn - I think you need to go back to some type of educational organisation and learn how to spell properly. Some extra study on grammar would be helpful also. I hope you are not writing any type of code.
    Then, once you've done that, read some history and see that whatever pay and condtions you are on, if you are employed, would be far worse than if Unions had not existed.
    You seem the type that might make a great Telstra 'Seagull' Manager.

    Small businesses will die Anonymous -- 02/09/08

    "Younger firms — and there is a plethora of them — along with smaller IT departments and telcos, need to consider how increased unionisation could affect their ability to do business."
    What is there to consider? The staff will want more money, the boss won't have it, the staff will somehow ignore the fact that money doesn't fall from the sky and strike anyway.
    Business over.

    Unions - or "Associations"? Anonymous -- 08/09/08

    Firstly, Unions (or some sort of club) are necessary while ever management (senior) have thier "clubs".
    Us IT workers DON'T have enough say to lever what we are entitled to.
    A recent survey discovered that in a lot of cases, IT workers are not as well paid as the myth would suggest. After a long career in a senior position, my wage is "average" for an average worker in my locality.
    A lot of workers (and I mean senior - experienced IT personel) have not had any sort of pay rise for over 5 years, in some cases 8 years.
    Yes, there are militant unions, but they only get involved because members support them - and they show interest.
    Maybe if APESMA (to my mind an ideal association to join) was a bit more overt as to it's accomplishments, they would attract more members.
    For what it's worth I AM a union member (no, not APESMA), and due to a total lack of interest in my issue with my company, I am resigning - to join a union that WILL show interest.
    If you don't like your Union - vote with your feet.

Add your opinion

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

Tags

Back to top

Featured