Motherload by Renai LeMay

Real men run quad-core CPUs and munch RAM with their Weetbix. Software is for wimps. Hardware is where all the cool stuff happens.

Do you suffer from phantom monitor pain?

Posted by Renai LeMay @ 12:35 35 comments

Every morning when I sit down at my ZDNet.com.au workstation, I feel totally discombobulated, like one of my limbs has been cut off without me noticing it. The reason, of course, is that I only have one monitor at work.

(Dual-Monitor Bluescreen image by Kim Scarborough, CC 2.0)

Not that I'm complaining; it's the best monitor I've ever had in a work environment. It's 22 inches of LCD goodness, and our helpful IT department has provided a beastly enough PC for me to be able to take advantage of the screen real estate; I can run all of my applications with no problems.

But it's still just one monitor.

At home I also have a 22-inch screen, but I've also recently added a discarded and ageing 17-inch screen that lost its primary use after our household bought an additional laptop.

This second screen has proven invaluable. I commonly drag a TweetDeck or instant messaging window onto it, just so I can keep an eye on what's happening in the real-time internet while I'm getting on with my main tasks; usually watching trailers of computer games, catching up on email, RSS feeds or just aimless surfing.

However, it's also useful whenever — which is often — I'm doing some serious writing at home. I often shift a browser window with source documents in separate tabs onto the secondary monitor and flick my eyes left to it whenever I need to refer to something.

This sort of set-up is easy to achieve in either Ubuntu or Windows (my primary home operating systems) with some minor tinkering. You can even find extended desktop wallpaper that will stretch across both monitors. The problem this creates for me in my work environment, though, is simply that I often automatically attempt to move a window across to the other monitor ... only to find there is no second monitor.

It's disconcerting, to say the least.

Do you suffer from phantom monitor pain? What can be done about this serious ailment? Do you encounter other hardware switching problems when moving between work and play?

Advertisement

Talkback 35 comments

    I feel your pain Anonymous -- 07/10/09

    Last year I had an operation which meant I had 12 stitches in my neck and couldn't turn it at all.

    With 2x24's on my desk I ended up turning one off. It was horrible...

    Awful Renai LeMay -- 07/10/09 (in reply to #320367495)

    Jeez that sounds awful. I hope it's all healed up now etc. Would have made work hard!

    Great!! Anonymous -- 29/10/09 (in reply to #320367495)

    I am not even in IT but I have a LCD monitor and my laptop on a docking station. Its awesome!! I will nevr go back to having 1 monitor again.

    Reverse situation Edward -- 07/10/09

    I have 2 monitors at work and 1 CRT monster at home - this phantom monitor situation does not effect me with this setup, however if it was reversed things would definitely get problematic. Two screens at work is almost a necessity and my company has recognised this, every employee has 2 monitors. All the engineers have 3 screens (30" + 2x20") which I consider overkill, but I bet they disagree.

    Bottom line, convince IT to get you another monitor! The efficiency benefits far outweigh the minimal cost, and chances are good your PC will have dual outputs (most do these days).

    Dual outputs Renai LeMay -- 07/10/09 (in reply to #320367532)

    30"?? Jeez that's fantastic. Where do you work Edward?

    Unfortunately my work PC (an off-the-shelf model) doesn't have dual monitor outputs. To support an additional monitor it would need an extra half-height graphics card to be inserted.

    I agree with you about the productivity benefits. It's hard to understand how great they are until you're really getting the advantage.

    Dual outputs Anonymous -- 08/10/09 (in reply to #320367598)

    Or try a USB graphics adapter. For less than $100 you can plug that old monitor into a usb port.

    I recently brought one from HP to give life to an old monitor but then upgraded to Win7 at home and the driver is not currently compatible so I'm back to just one ... and the other just stares blankly at me waiting for me to sort it out.

    USB adapter Renai LeMay -- 09/10/09 (in reply to #320373098)

    I hadn't seen this one before ... but does it really provide OK performance?

    USB adapter Anonymous -- 28/10/09 (in reply to #320374747)

    Okay, but not as great for video as the main screen, but still very good.

    Good for having docs or email open while you work on something else.

    I suffer the reverse Mel Sommersberg -- 07/10/09

    I have two monitors at work and use a laptop at home so I guess I have reverse phantom monitor pain.

    My only gripe at work is that the second monitor is 50mm smaller than the main one and it looks a little strange however it still does the job. It is used for monitoring security cameras.

    Security cameras Renai LeMay -- 08/10/09 (in reply to #320367911)

    Now that is an idea Mel! Would be hilarious to put a security camera on the front of my house and watch passersby going by!

    Maybe also illegal ;)

    More efficient at home with more monitors Anonymous -- 07/10/09

    About a year ago, I started working form home more as I needed more power and more screen real estate than the 17" (late two).

    I have an i7 system with 3 x 30" and 1 x 24", as I usually have Access open in one 30" (multiple queries and tables open), two Word instances and sometimes XML Notepad in the second 30", a two (or three) Windows Explorers and a source file or few in Notepad++ in the third 30", and Outlook, several Gadgets and the Taskbar in the 24". And still wish I had more occasionally.

    Even my wife who was used to a 10" laptop for years, now has a quadcore, 30", 20" and a 27", and wouldn't look back!

    If you need to be able to quickly go between large apps windows, the more pixels the better.

    Uber Renai LeMay -- 08/10/09 (in reply to #320368130)

    Jeez that sounds fantastic! I only wish I could afford similar.

    Well, I guess I could buy them, but it would seriously eat into my savings ;)

    Originally for audio recording Anonymous -- 08/10/09 (in reply to #320372471)

    I gradually increased the sizes and numbers of monitors over time to handle audio recording, but working from home made getting the third 30" pay for itself.

    I must say that the Win7 window manipulation shortcuts have saved me hours over the last few months.

    Win7 Renai LeMay -- 09/10/09 (in reply to #320372485)

    Yeah I use them too ... so much more flexible and usable than WinXP or Vista!

    phantom jon -- 07/10/09

    I lost a leg in a crash and suffer from phantom limb ... but your problem is much worse obviously!

    dual = the norm !?!? Anonymous -- 08/10/09

    Isn't dual monitor a norm in any IT environment? It has been proven time and again that such a setup does increase productivity! Or maybe I have been just lucky with the work places that I have been.

    The norm Renai LeMay -- 08/10/09 (in reply to #320372309)

    It surely, surely is not the norm, I have to say :)

    I would say very few companies have dual monitor setups beyond a few select staff.

    Too bad Paul -- 08/10/09

    Your old desk over at Fairfax has two screens now Renai .... you should've stayed put ;-)

    Nice! Renai LeMay -- 08/10/09 (in reply to #320372334)

    Nice! Now if you could only just ship one over here to me, that would be perfect :)

    Maximum problems Anonymous -- 08/10/09

    Our IT department (where I work) all have dual monitors, and it's wonderful: reference material on the left, program code or document on the right. We wanted to roll out the benefits to the rest of the admin staff but the cost was too high. So we compromised and went 22" wide-screens instead. Previously, everybody maximised their apps on their 17" 4:3 screens. AND THEY STILL DO! I can't believe!! How can you read text efficiently when each line is 22 inches wide?? It's ludicrous , but they continue do it even after being shown how to lay out their specifications and their work so they can see both. The productivity improvement is probably around negative 8%.

    Really? Renai LeMay -- 08/10/09 (in reply to #320372377)

    Really?

    I have found that a 22" is a good size for any application, but it's only a good size for more than one on-screen at the same time if it has limited requirements.

    For example, I prefer Firefox full-screen, but I can have a PDF document and a Word document I'm typing in open at the same time.

    Can only fit twobusy web pages on 30"! Anonymous -- 08/10/09 (in reply to #320372476)

    For sites of articles like ZD-Net, I have the main page on the left and drag a hyperlink to a browser on the right to open an article. It saves back button time just to go to another article.

    However, such busy web pages take up so much space (1024 pixels minimum), I can only fit two on a 30" monitor (2560px wide).

    ... Anonymous -- 08/10/09

    slow news day renai?

    Actually it wasn't! Renai LeMay -- 08/10/09 (in reply to #320372759)

    We had a stack of stuff happening yesterday :) This wasn't a news story in any case, it was a blog post. Opinion and commentary :)

    ouch Kelli -- 09/10/09 (in reply to #320372759)

    anon, clearly you have not felt this pain. tis big news, in fact...fellow sufferers understand...

    The pain the pain Anonymous -- 08/10/09

    At home I have a 24" and 22" widescreen monitors & its great.

    Going to work is horrible.
    I have one tiny crappy old 15" LCD monitor at work that I can hardly see. My suggestions that they get up-to-date with 20-22" widescreen monitors were met with looks of bemused horror.

    At home I have a 24" and 22" widescreen monitors & its great.

    15"???????? Renai LeMay -- 08/10/09 (in reply to #320372773)

    Sounds like it's time to work somewhere else. 22" monitors only cost a couple of hundred dollars these days ... small price to pay for improved satisfaction and productivity.

    Poor window management in Windows does not help.... Michael Buckley -- 08/10/09

    Two screens are good, but I think a lot of there advantage can be given by better window management. Here I am thinking of the multiple virtual desktops that any Linux setup with give you. It makes flicking between groups of windows so much easier.

    I have a 24" monitor which I connect to my laptop

    The old MultiDesk will o it as well Anonymous -- 09/10/09 (in reply to #320373091)

    The older MultiDesk utilitiy (not v2) works very well, even on Win7, retaining Aero functionality as well. Also allows easy setting of which windows appear on all desktops.

    However, multiple desktops don't really do it if you need to see all the information. It is fine for configuration screens on lesser used desktops, or mutually exclusive worspaces. Just not for interrelated information.

    Interrelated information Renai LeMay -- 09/10/09 (in reply to #320374636)

    Yeah, this is my problem. I do have multiple desktops set up on Ubuntu, but if you want to look at two things at the same time it doesn't really help ...

    Don't have this problem at all Anonymous -- 09/10/09

    I've has dual monitors at work for 3-4 years now. Some people even have 3 or 4. It is so useful - but my current work recognises the benefits of having more than one, as did the last place I worked - so surely its not that unusual? Maybe where you work is behind the times...

    Behind the times Renai LeMay -- 09/10/09 (in reply to #320374659)

    I would agree that companies that have a lot of "information worker" type staff that don't provide multiple monitors to them are a bit behind the times ... however you also have to take into account the practical business consequences etc.

    30" monitors are not cheap. If you're gonna roll them out, you will want to do it as a whole; if only part of the organisation get them, the rest will be jealous.

    The ideal world business case is not the same as the real world business case ;)

    Opposite Morgan -- 09/10/09

    I have the opposite as well.
    Three screens at work, laptop screen 22" connected to laptop dock and a 17" connected to a USB video card.
    At home the best I can do is laptop and a 22" heh.
    My best effort at home used to be 5 screens, 3 being old laptops running synergy to share the keyboard and mouse.

    work computer Anonymous -- 10/10/09

    At work I have a thin client with a 17" LCD. When I type-on an ancient keyboard- the buffer is 3 lines behind me. I am being driven out of my mind. At home I use a laptop but it has a 17.5" screen and I have a 22" monitor set up permanently next to it. I second the notion that Windows 7 make this setup really easy to use.

    dual power! paul -- 13/10/09

    renai, I hear you buddy =P

    I recently managed to scrounge up enough wires and screens recently to get the old dual screen pumping at work, already have at least two converts =P

    lets hope everyone catches on to the power of dual screenism, so that noone has to miss out!

Add your opinion

Renai LeMay

Renai LeMay

News Editor

[+] Read bio

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Tags

Back to top

Featured