Don't Fall for IT by Munir Kotadia

The world of tech is full of broken promises, marketing spin and schizophrenic behaviour. Munir Kotadia, editor of ZDNet Australia, attempts to bypass the drivel and tell IT like it is.

Tax Office needs to rethink open source objections

Posted by Munir Kotadia @ 12:58 4 comments

The Australian Tax Office CIO Bill Gibson claims that one of the reasons he hasn't deployed much open source software is due to security fears, with the code not subject to enough "technical scrutiny".

In order to watch video content you need to enable javascript and install Flash player version 8 or above.

"We are very, very focused on security and privacy and the obligations we have ... We would need to make sure that we are very comfortable through some form of technical scrutiny of what is inside such a product so that there is nothing unforeseen there," he told ZDNet.com.au in a video interview.

Will open source software ever become ubiquitous in government?

I find it interesting that Gibson trusts software from proprietary vendors who keep their code a secret but distrusts open source vendors, who lay out their code for anyone to see.

If this is the prevailing attitude among CIOs, it seems like the open source movement still has a very long struggle ahead.

The full interview with Gibson will be published today on the ZDNet.com.au CIO Vision Series page.

Advertisement

Talkback 4 comments

  1. Someone to blame Anonymous -- 18/03/08

    You/re obviously unfamiliar with the way public service works....

    When things go wrong, and they always eventually do, you need pass the buck.. i,e. its the softwares vendors fault, we weren't told, we'll sue...

    You don't get that option with open source, i.e. you're responsible. This is why open source has a hard road to travel, unless you get it from Red Hat or Novell

    1. you make no sense Anonymous -- 18/03/08

      "You don't get that option with open source, i.e. you're responsible. This is why open source has a hard road to travel, unless you get it from Red Hat or Novell"

      So you are not alone and you can blame Red Hat or Novell. buy from them. simple. i think you have spent too much time in "public service"

  2. Public service is about... Anonymous -- 03/04/08

    I think "public service" is about providing quality services to citizens at the best price possible and not checking that you have someone to blame if something goes wrong.

    The impact of software choices on local economy should also be taken in consideration.

    Is the service better when public servants use a 400$ or 500$ MS Office software or just the same as with a 0$ OpenOffice ?

    What par of this n x 400$ goes in local economy and what part abroad ?

    1. boy are you deluded xBeanie -- 13/05/08

      I have sat in a meeting where two options were deliberately and explicitly positioned to the manager as the more technically risky option and the more personally risky (to the managers career) option. Of course, like all good public service managers he immediately chose the more technically risky option where there was more chance of system failure but he would be able to deny any responsibility.

Add your opinion


Munir Kotadia

Munir Kotadia

Editor

[+] Read bio

ZDNet's CIO Vision Series

Customs | Murray Harrison, CIO

Australian Customs CIO Murray Harrison dislikes SLAs and runs away if a vendor talks to him about innovation. In this interview, he also explains why getting excited about gadgets can be dangerous and talks about how Customs' outsourcing strategy has evolved.

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Tags

Back to top

Featured