Big Picture by Sheryle Moon

As children, parents and teachers were our mentors, but as adults in the working world, mentors can be hard to find. In Big Picture, industry leaders share their views, experience, advice and tips on making today’s followers tomorrow’s leaders.

Women in ICT a rare breed

Posted by Sheryle Moon @ 13:26 8 comments

Friday was International Women's Day -- a perfect opportunity to examine the appalling lack of women in ICT.

A quick scan of almost any ICT department, ICT conference or vendor environment -- from the trenches to the corner office -- confirms that women who embrace technology as a lifelong career remain a rare breed.

There is no doubt that the opportunities for women in technology have advanced in the past few decades, as have education initiatives aimed at levelling the playing field and attracting women into the industry.

The industry as a whole, however, continues to suffer a skills shortage that is only worsening. A recent study by Swinburne University of Technology substantiates the drastic decline in ICT graduates entering the workforce, with overall enrolments falling by 46 percent since 2001.

And within this trend, the ratio of women to men continues to decline: in the seven years since 2001, the proportion of women enrolling in ICT courses in Australia dropped 6 percent to 20 percent on average.

Against the backdrop of plummeting enrolments, this represents a staggering 51 percent decline in the number of women studying ICT. For every woman rising to prominence or embarking on a career in IT or undertaking an IT course at university, there is another opting out.

This is despite recent Australian research from James Cook University, which concludes that women find ICT to be a rewarding, socially useful and satisfying career. On the whole, women disagree with prevailing negative stereotypes about the wider industry.

Yet the reasons women give for leaving are the same ones I heard two decades ago: they are the micro inequalities such as wage discrimination, the "boys' club" and the lack of work/life balance. The James Cook study suggests that this may be an organisational problem founded in management practices, and not one that is necessarily entrenched in a wider industry culture.

What remains unspoken in much of the discussion surrounding these issues is the effect this increasing imbalance will have on the long-term prospects of the IT industry and individual companies. Where organisational demographics do not represent the social diversity of the marketplace, their ability to anticipate and meet the demands of consumers is seriously compromised.

And women bring different, and equally important skills to the workplace. Addressing the number of women in the workforce is important to establish the kinds of adaptive, collaborative and versatile enterprises that will thrive in the fast-paced global economy.

More than just stemming the tide of the ongoing skills shortages, encouraging women to get involved in the production of ICT goods and services is imperative for the competitive advantage of Australian organisations and the wider industry.

Advertisement

Talkback 8 comments

    We need to inspire them! Anonymous -- 12/03/08

    Many younger girls see ICT as a boring career option (and are option actively talked out of it by careers advisors, but that is another issue!). We need to inspire young women (and men) to get into the industry by showing them how interesting, fun, satisfying and awesome it is! This means marketing and PR towards young people, careers advisors, teachers and parents.

    We also need to change the masculine/feminine debate and change the perception of ICT as being gender neutral. After all, there is nothing overtly masculine about ICT, and yet it is still mistakenly seen as a boys thing, when girls are enormous users of technology! This is one of the biggest differences between Australia and Malaysia which has a far higher percentage of women in ICT (from technical to management).

    Also, young people today are more socially aware than ever before. With this in mind I think the One Laptop per Child project provides an opportunity to lure more girls into ICT as they can see how technology can change the world for the better, and have fun doing it!

    Thank you for your insightful and informative posts Sheryle.

    Mannnny factors Anonymous -- 14/03/08

    Women see the current state of the industry and simply vote with their feet. I think they are doing so for the following reasons:

    1. IT has an image problem. It is still seen as the domain of geeks and nerds.

    2. The work life balance is almost non existent. IT pros are expected to do whatever it takes to get the job done.

    3. The never ending skills upgrade cycle. Who would be stupid enough to get into a field where their skills are made obsolete every 5 or so years.

    4. The dopey hiring practices with HR managers and Recruiters often running word match searches against resumes. If your CV is missing the key words in the job spec, you don't even get past the first stage of the recruitment process.

    5. This is the big one. OUTSOURCING. Why on earth would anyone join an industry in a constant race to the bottom in terms of costs? Damn all other consequences.

    6. The attitude of employers. Most employers treat IT pros like something stuck to their shoes.

    I guess when you look at all of the above, there is nothing specific to women. It's just that women are cleverer than men, and so when they see the above factors, they run for the hills. The male counterpart is a little let's say slower to comprehend this.

    So in general, there is NO great conspiracy against the sisterhood.

    And finally, IT is a left-brain field which is typically something that males are better at. It's the same with Engineering and most other Analytical jobs.

    When you get more girls wanting to study Maths at school (not just to get a better HSC score), you will get more women in Engineering, IT and Science.

    Who knows Anonymous -- 14/03/08

    Crazy idea, but maybe on the whole, chicks just aren't as interested in IT as guys are?

    There aren't many female mechanics either, maybe JCU should do a study on that as well...

    How disappointing Rebecca -- 18/03/08 (in reply to #320097301)

    I dispute the fact that women aren't as interested in IT as men. That's a redundant and foolish stereotype. I'm a woman and I work in a profession dominated by women, so I'm generally sheltered from that kind of prejudice and I'm disappointed (though not surprised) to see it appear here.

    The fact that the previous commenter chooses to refer to women as 'chicks' indicates a general lack of understanding of and respect for women. Perhaps the commenter (oh brave 'Anonymous') really means that women shouldn't be allowed to be interested in IT. History tells such chauvinists that it's best to educate the womenfolk as little as possible to prevent us making outrageous claims to spheres dominated by menfolk. Back in the kitchen, barefoot and pregnant apparently.

    Rubbish Matt -- 19/03/08

    Another "anecdotally driven" poorly researched pile of junk from the Moonster.

    Jobs should go to the best person that applies. We should NEVER artificially lower the bar to increase representation from any sex or race.

    Work/Life balance issues apply equally to all IT people. IT IS A FACT that IT work generally needs to happen when the end users are not needing systems. Weekends, after hours etc.

    We work longer hours, more irregular hours and get paid very little for it.

    It is fact of life that the career that we often aspire to is not quite what we percieve it to be.

    IT is NOT sexy, it is not the hub of all things, it is just another job type.

    Why I left Anonymous -- 02/04/08

    I was in IT and loved it. But then reality hit. My work was outsourced to India and I lost my job. I was looking to get back into it for three years without any luck.

    So I went back to finish my civil engineering degree (already got a BSc) and am now working as a cadet engineer while having my studies paid for.

    I would not recommend IT to my worst enemy. IT is under constant threat of being outsourced. There is no reason why software development and indeed, software and hardware support, cannot be outsourced to a foreign country at any time. Job security is horrendous.

    Women are not stupid. They do not let their hearts rule their minds when it comes to job security. IT is not cutting it, hence lack of interest by the female of the species, and rightly so.

    A good thing really Anonymous -- 04/04/08

    Why do we perceive we need more women in the industry? It's clear that the vast majority of women lack critical elements of the brain that drive analytical and logical decisions. Better off to leave them where emotion based decisions are more acceptable. Social work, Care workers, personal training.. lots of places where they're better suited.

    There are lots of us in Sweden Lise-Lott Holm -- 07/04/08

    In Sweden we have a lot of women in ICT. Especially in sales, were women are quite successful.
    We seem to be more customer oriented and less product nerds...

Add your opinion

Sheryle Moon

Sheryle Moon

CEO, Australian Information Industry Association

[+] Read bio

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Tags

Back to top

Featured